Commonwealth Report Findings Land and water For policymakers Elected Officials Updates Weekly Method Search

Dukes County · West Tisbury, the front page ›

West Tisbury

Town · Dukes County · 3,080 residents (ACS 2020–24)

Data through FY2026; built November 9, 2026.

State House

State Senate

School districts

Regional planning agency

Martha's Vineyard Commission

Habitat, forest and water

West Tisbury: Land and Water ↗

This is what the state sends your town: aid, grants and earmarks, and how they compare with towns like it. What the money has to cover is on the other pages: the roads in flood zones, the land the state holds here, and the legislators whose posts shape the earmarks.

West Tisbury, in brief

West Tisbury is a town of 3,080 people on 25.0 square miles of Dukes County, 123 to the square mile, less densely settled than most of the state. Median household income is $183,000, above the median town’s $114,000. State aid covered 6.7% of its general-fund spending in FY2025; the median town’s share was 11.5%. On the Fairness Index it scores 53 for all state aid and 46 for discretionary money — about its share on both. Its Land and Water Index is 61, 113th of 351. The state owns 15% of its land, on which it paid $1.7 million in lieu of taxes in FY2026, $679 an acre against $117 statewide. The forest now covers about 57% of the town, up from the 11% the surveyors drew in 1830. 48% of its housing units are seasonal. On the strong side: school-building grants approved for schools serving it come to $4,143 per resident, 18th of 351; 54% of its land, 8,642 acres, is mapped core habitat, 29th of 351 in the state; 44% of the town is protected open space of one owner or another.

Where it comes up short: no earmark reached the town government in ten enacted state budgets; $45,000 was placed with organizations in town; 66% of its assessed lake acres and river miles are on the state’s impaired list — algae; measured against what it maintains, it received 59% of its proportional share of competitive grants.

The openings are specific: its ten nearest peers’ median earmark per resident is $49.39 against its own $14.61, so towns like it do receive earmarks; $398,000 of its Chapter 90 road money is apportioned and not yet drawn. The risks are equally specific: beech leaf disease, southern pine beetle have been mapped in town by the aerial survey since 2019; it owns one high- or significant-hazard dam.

Written by rule from the figures on this page: each clause appears only when the town sits well away from the middle of the state on that measure, so a shorter story means a more ordinary record. Every figure is in the cards below with its source.

West Tisbury · 25.0 square miles

Fairness Index · all state aid

53 / 100

102nd of 351

Fifty is a fair share.

See the index ›

Fairness Index · discretionary money

46 / 100

205th of 351

Grants and earmarks only.

See the index ›

Land and Water Index

61 / 100

113th of 351

Fifty is the median town.

Full land page ›

At a glance

  1. Fairness IndexWest Tisbury scores 53 on the Fairness Index for all state aid and 46 for discretionary money. Fifty is a fair share.Read more ›
  2. State moneyWest Tisbury’s town government and school districts received $34.9 million in formula aid and $960,000 in competitive grants over ten years.Read more ›
  3. EarmarksWest Tisbury received $0 in local earmarks to its government, $45,000 placed in the city or town and $45,000 counting everything placed, in ten enacted state budgets.Read more ›
  4. Aid and chargesIn FY2027 the state’s cherry sheet sends West Tisbury $2 million and takes back $237,000 in assessments and charges, a net $1.8 million.Read more ›
  5. Money to othersState programs also awarded $136,000 to organizations in West Tisbury other than the town government, FY2016–FY2027.Read more ›
  6. Expected and actualWest Tisbury received $3.7 million in earmarks placed in the city or town and competitive grants over ten years, 79% of the $4.7 million its size, need and institutions predict.Read more ›
  7. What the town carriesMeasured against what it maintains, West Tisbury received 59% of its proportional share of competitive grant awards.Read more ›
  8. Roads and bridgesWest Tisbury has $398,000 of Chapter 90 road money from FY2017–FY2026 not yet reimbursed; it owns no bridges rated poor and one high- or significant-hazard dam.Read more ›
  9. Costs and the 2½% limitState aid covered 6.7% of West Tisbury’s general-fund spending in FY2025, up from 5.9% in FY2006.Read more ›
  10. State landWest Tisbury has 2,444 acres of mapped state conservation and recreation land and 98 acres of land coded as chapter land.Read more ›
  11. Habitat and waterWest Tisbury has 8,642 acres of mapped core habitat, 54% of its land area; 2,988 of those acres are outside any protected land.Read more ›
  12. SchoolsWest Tisbury’s required school contribution is 2.5% of median household income, 211th highest of 351.Read more ›
  13. School buildingsThe Massachusetts School Building Authority approved grants of up to $12.8 million for schools serving West Tisbury, FY2017 to August 2026.Read more ›
  14. PeersWest Tisbury ranks 8th of 11 on earmark dollars placed in the city or town per resident among itself and its ten nearest peers.Read more ›

Fairness Index

West Tisbury scores 53 on the Fairness Index for all state aid and 46 for discretionary money. Fifty is a fair share.

All state aid

53 / 100102nd of 351 (1 = most above its share)

Equal
45
Need
69
Burden
43
Effort
52

Rank under other weightings: 68th to 135th.

Weighting-dependent: the range crosses the 45–55 band

West Tisbury received less than its share of state aid on two of four measures; its blended score of 53 stays between 48 and 58 under every weighting tested.

Discretionary money only

46 / 100205th of 351 (1 = most above its share)

Equal
42
Need
66
Burden
28
Effort
49

Rank under other weightings: 176th to 224th.

Weighting-dependent: the range crosses the 45–55 band

West Tisbury received less than its share of discretionary money on three of four measures; its blended score of 46 stays between 40 and 53 under every weighting tested.

Each bar is one way of defining a fair share: Equal, the same per resident; Need, weighted toward poverty, low income and a thin tax base; Burden, by what each program pays for (road miles, bridges, pupils and so on); Effort, by what residents already pay in property tax relative to their income. The line marks 50. The score is the average of the four. Discretionary money is competitive grants and earmarks to the city or town government. How the index is built.

State money, FY2017–FY2026

West Tisbury’s town government and school districts received $34.9 million in formula aid and $960,000 in competitive grants over ten years.

Formula aid

$34.9M

$11,333 per resident (139th of 351) · gross

Competitive grants

$960,000

$312 per resident (203rd of 351)

Earmark-account payments

$0

$0 per resident (339th of 351)

Competitive grants to West Tisbury peaked in FY2026 at $500,000, 52% of the ten-year total.
Formula aid$34.9M total · peak $4.9M in FY2026
Competitive grants$960,000 total · peak $500,000 in FY2026
Earmark-account payments$0 total · none recorded
FY17FY18FY19FY20FY21FY22FY23FY24FY25FY26

Each class has its own scale. Bars show dollars paid in each fiscal year.

Formula aid is gross: Chapter 70 as DESE attributes it to the town, and cherry-sheet aid before the state deducts charges such as charter tuition and transit assessments, plus other formula programs as paid. Competitive grants and earmark-account payments are Comptroller payments to the town government and its school districts (stage: paid), the same payees as the Fairness Index. Enacted earmarks and earmark payments are different things: enacted earmarks are budget clauses, counted three ways above; earmark-account payments are Comptroller payments to the town government and its school districts from accounts classified as earmarks, which can include prior-year and statewide-program money. Either can be larger. Shared revenue, pass-through contracts, transfers to state entities and unclassified payments, $5.2M in all, are not shown. Rank 1 is the highest amount per resident among 351.

Earmarks

West Tisbury received $0 in local earmarks to its government, $45,000 placed in the city or town and $45,000 counting everything placed, in ten enacted state budgets.

To the city or town government

$0

enacted, ten state budgets

Placed in the city or town

$45,000

$14.61 per resident (294th of 351) · all to organizations

Everything placed

$45,000

$14.61 per resident (295th of 351) · all to organizations

No earmarks in ten state budgets

No

35 municipalities had none

Local earmarks are counted three ways: money to West Tisbury’s government, its schools or municipal projects; money placed in West Tisbury, adding organizations; and everything placed, adding state facilities located here. Three ways to count a local earmark.

Placed in the city or town: two clauses in two of ten state budgets; the most recent in FY2026. $0 went to West Tisbury’s government, its schools or municipal projects; the other $45,000 went to organizations in West Tisbury or named with it, some of which serve a wider area.

Every local earmark in West Tisbury, FY2017–FY2026, largest first (two clauses; the town’s share where a clause names several towns)
YearAmountBudget text (excerpt)Stage
FY2024$25,000“Martha’s Vineyard Community Foundation, Inc. to provide transportation services to older adults on Martha’s Vineyard”Enacted
organization based here
FY2026$20,000“Martha’s Vineyard Community Foundation, Inc. for costs associated with transportation for older adults on Martha’s Vineyard”Enacted
organization based here

Enacted earmarks and earmark payments are different things: enacted earmarks are budget clauses, counted three ways above; earmark-account payments are Comptroller payments to the town government and its school districts from accounts classified as earmarks, which can include prior-year and statewide-program money. Either can be larger.

What the state sends and takes back

In FY2027 the state’s cherry sheet sends West Tisbury $2 million and takes back $237,000 in assessments and charges, a net $1.8 million.

Sent: estimated receipts

$2 million

FY2027 cherry sheet

Taken back: assessments and charges

$237,000

12% of what is sent

Net

$1.8 million

receipts less charges

What the state sends
LineFY2027
Unrestricted General Government Aid$249,000
Exemp: VBS and Elderly$20,000
State Owned Land$1.7M
Public Libraries$12,000
What the state takes back
LineFY2027
County Tax$77,000
Air Pollution Districts$3,947
RMV Non-Renewal Surcharge$5,780
Regional Transit$150,000

Source: Division of Local Services, FY2027 cherry sheets (C.S. 1-ER receipts and C.S. 1-EC charges), final. Charges include county tax, mosquito control, air pollution districts, planning councils, the MBTA and regional transit, and tuition the town pays for its students who attend charter schools or other districts by school choice. In towns that belong to a regional school district, Chapter 70 goes to the district, not the town, so it does not appear here.

State money to others in West Tisbury

State programs also awarded $136,000 to organizations in West Tisbury other than the town government, FY2016–FY2027.

These are competitive grants to nonprofits, tribal nations, regional bodies, state agencies and businesses located in or serving West Tisbury. They are listed for completeness. They are not counted in the town’s state money or its Fairness Index, because the money does not go to the town government. Where a program has a measure of need for the town, these awards do enter the burden index above; where it has none, they are left out of it. Many of these organizations serve a wider area than the town where they are based.

Awards to named organizations (the town’s share where an award names several towns)
YearRecipientProgramAmount
FY2022Friends of MVYRADIO nonprofitCultural Facilities Fund$60,000
FY2019Sheriff's Meadow Foundation nonprofitMassTrails Grants$10,000 (shared two ways)
FY2019Martha’s Vineyard Commission regional bodyCommunity Compact Efficiency & Regionalization Grant$5,000 (shared seven ways)

A further $61,000 in 1 award went to businesses, farms and recipients the source does not name; they are counted here but not named, because a farm or small business often carries a family’s name.

Source: the project’s award catalog (state agency award lists and announcements); awards marked as counting toward totals. Earmarks to organizations based in the town are in the earmarks section above, on the second and third measures.

Expected and actual

West Tisbury received $3.7 million in earmarks placed in the city or town and competitive grants over ten years, 79% of the $4.7 million its size, need and institutions predict.

Expected
$4.7M
Received
$3.7M

The expectation comes from a statewide model of all 351 municipalities that uses population, road miles, jobs, poverty, income, tax base, school-aid share and the presence of hospitals, colleges and nonprofits. Those factors explain about 55–60% of the differences between towns. The model leaves out many legitimate reasons a town may receive more or less, such as a single large project, so a gap is a starting point for questions, not a finding about anyone’s conduct.

Earmarks here are placed in the city or town, the second of three measures (enacted); competitive grants are Comptroller payments (paid). Of the earmarks counted here, $45,000 (all of them) went to organizations based in West Tisbury. Method.

What the town carries

Measured against what it maintains, West Tisbury received 59% of its proportional share of competitive grant awards.

Local road miles

14.2

347th of 351 · 4.6 per 1,000 residents (256th of 351)

Town-owned bridges, replacement cost

$0

scored exposure $0 · counts and condition under Roads, bridges and dams

Road-stream crossings

70

196th of 351 · culverts and small crossings

Town-owned hazard dams

1

high or significant hazard

Land area

25.0 sq mi

15% state-owned

Seasonal homes

48%

share of housing units

Peak service population

6,224

residents plus seasonal

Core infrastructure index

0.32

roads, culverts, dams, coast, flood, energy

The burden index divides the competitive awards West Tisbury received from FY2017 to FY2026 by what it would have received if every program had split its money by its own measure of need: road miles for road programs, crossings for culvert grants, town-owned hazard dams for dam repair, jobs for economic development, residents for libraries. 1.0 is proportional. West Tisbury: 0.59. State median: 0.91. Bridges count by replacement cost and condition, not by number, and only bridges the town owns. For the index, bridges are valued from the 2025 inventories at the federal unit cost, and a bridge on a town line is shared among the towns it touches; the Roads, bridges and dams section counts them from MassDOT’s current inventory, so its counts can differ slightly. Ranks run from 1, the most among 351.

State land and growth

State land eligible for PILOT

2,475 acres

15.4% of land area · FY2026

State-owned land PILOT, FY2026

$1.7M

payment in lieu of taxes, cherry sheet

PILOT per eligible acre

$679

statewide $117 · FY2026

New growth per resident

$95,161

FY2017–2025 · 10th of 351 · median town $20,524

State land eligible for PILOT is the Division of Local Services’ count of state-owned acres on which the state pays a payment in lieu of taxes; the payment follows the land’s assessed value, not its acreage, so the per-acre figure is a comparison, not the formula. The state-owned share on the land-area tile above is the MassGIS map of all state-owned open space, a wider count. New growth is the assessed value of new construction and improvements added to the tax base, summed FY2017–FY2025 and divided by 2020–24 residents; taxed at the prior year’s rates, it adds to the levy limit beyond 2.5%.

Roads, bridges and dams

West Tisbury has $398,000 of Chapter 90 road money from FY2017–FY2026 not yet reimbursed; it owns no bridges rated poor and one high- or significant-hazard dam.

Chapter 90 apportioned, FY2017–FY2027

$1.4M

$424,000 of it one-time supplements

Reimbursed against it

$901,000

to 16 October 2026

Not yet reimbursed, FY2017–FY2026 money

$398,000

annual program: 1.1 years of its yearly money · 193rd of 351

Town-owned bridges

0

none rated poor

High- or significant-hazard dams

1

of one town-owned dam

Bridge, dam and culvert grants, FY2017–FY2026

$0

bridges $0 · dams $0 · culverts $0

Chapter 90 is the state’s main road program. MassDOT apportions it to every city and town by a formula, and the town is reimbursed after it spends the money on approved work. Counting each payment against the town’s oldest money first, payments to West Tisbury came on average 62 months after the start of the year the money was apportioned for. Statewide, $655 million of FY2017–FY2026 apportionments was not yet reimbursed on 16 October 2026; counting the annual program alone, the median town held about 1.2 years of its yearly money. Money not yet reimbursed is not the same as idle money: MassDOT’s Chapter 90 Advisory Group found 63% of the unspent balance committed to approved projects not yet billed (January 2025).

West Tisbury owns one high- or significant-hazard dam and received no dam award from the Dam and Seawall or Municipal Vulnerability Preparedness programs, FY2017–FY2026.

Chapter 90 by state fiscal year
YearAnnual apportionmentOne-time supplementsReimbursed in the year (any year’s money)Year-end balance, FY2017-on money
FY2017$82,000$0$88,000$82,000
FY2018$83,000$0$0$165,000
FY2019$82,000$16,000$0$264,000
FY2020$82,000$8,158$0$353,000
FY2021$81,000$0$0$435,000
FY2022$80,000$46,000$0$562,000
FY2023$84,000$0$149,000$574,000
FY2024$84,000$152,000$192,000$742,000
FY2025$84,000$127,000$429,000$524,000
FY2026$132,000$74,000$332,000$398,000
FY2027 (to 16 Oct)$132,000$0$0$530,000

The full list of the three bridges in West Tisbury in MassDOT’s inventory, with each one’s condition, is on the town’s page at massanomics.com/commonwealth.

Every bridge in West Tisbury

Three bridges in MassDOT’s inventory, none rated poor and none closed, worst first. The list includes bridges the town does not own; costs are shown for town-owned bridges only. Tap the i beside a heading for what it means.

Bridges in West Tisbury, MassDOT inventory
BridgeCarriesCrossesTypeOwnerBuiltLowest ratingConditionStatusLast inspectedProposed work
W23001State RdMill BrookShort spanMassDOT1850
rebuilt 1900
5Fair deck 5 · super 5 · sub 6Open2026-06-16
W23003Edgtn-w TisbMill Pond OtltShort spanMassDOT1850
rebuilt 1900
5Fair deck 7 · super 7 · sub 5Open2026-06-16
W23002State RdTiasquam RiverShort spanMassDOT18507Good deck 7 · super 7 · sub 7Open2026-06-16

Chapter 90: MassDOT apportionments and the Comptroller’s payment records (CTHRU), FY2017–FY2027; “not yet reimbursed” means apportioned money not found in the payment records. Bridges: MassDOT’s bridge inventory and the federal National Bridge Inventory, town-owned structures only; a bridge on a town line counts in part to each town. Dams: Office of Dam Safety inventory, town-owned only. Repair grants: EEA, Division of Ecological Restoration and MassDOT award lists. These amounts are not in the town’s state money totals above. Method.

Costs and the 2½% limit

State aid covered 6.7% of West Tisbury’s general-fund spending in FY2025, up from 5.9% in FY2006.

State aid as a share of general-fund spending

FY2006

5.9%

$720,000 of $12.1M · median town 14.1%

FY2016

6.9%

$1.2M of $17.1M · median town 12.2%

FY2025

6.7%

$1.7M of $25.4M · median town 11.5%

Net of state charges, FY2025

5.9%

FY2010: 5.3% · median town 10.0%

State aid is the gross cherry sheet as entered on the tax rate recap; spending is the town’s general-fund expenditures as filed with the Division of Local Services. Net subtracts the charges the state assesses on the same cherry sheet (charter and school-choice tuition, transit, county and other assessments), itemized from FY2010.

West Tisbury’s own cherry sheet carries no Chapter 70 for pupils in its regional district; the state paid $1.3 million in FY2025 Chapter 70 to the district on its behalf, outside these figures, while the town’s assessment to the district sits in its spending. For a regional member the share understates state support for school costs.

West Tisbury’s state aid kept pace with both price measures: FY2025 aid was 53.1% above its FY2006 aid grown by Boston-area consumer prices and 36.0% above grown by the government price index.
FY2006 aid
$720,000
At FY2025 consumer prices
$1.1M
At FY2025 government prices
$1.3M
FY2025 aid
$1.7M

Gross state aid went from $720,000 in FY2006 to $1.7 million in FY2025, +137.4% in dollars. Consumer prices are the Boston-area CPI-U, up 55.1% over those years; government prices are the federal price index for state and local government purchases, up 74.5%. Fiscal-year averages. Flag: in FY2010, $237,000 of West Tisbury’s gross aid was in receipts the itemized cherry sheet does not show, consistent with school-building reimbursements that ended by FY2024 (not verified line by line). Part of the change since FY2006 may be that phase-out.

Fixed costs against the 2½% limit, FY2016–FY2025

Health insurance, FY2016–25

+54.7%

$646,000 to $1,000,000 · all towns +54.0%

All fixed costs, FY2016–25

+65.2%

$1.1M to $1.8M · all towns +53.0%

Years squeezed

7 of 9

fixed costs grew faster than allowed levy growth

Health insurance

7 of 9

years it grew faster than allowed levy growth

Nine years at 2.5% add 24.9%. Grown that way from FY2016, West Tisbury’s health insurance would have been $807,000 in FY2025; it was $1,000,000, $193,000 above the path. Its fixed costs would have been $1.36 million in FY2025; it was $1.80 million, $439,000 above the path.

Fixed costs are employee benefits, retirement, insurance and similar costs in the general fund; health insurance comes from a separate DLS report. Allowed levy growth is 2.5% plus new growth, as a share of the prior year’s levy limit; a year counts as squeezed when fixed costs grew by a larger percentage.

Local earmarks against the health-insurance increase

Over the nine budgets, earmarks to West Tisbury’s government came to $0, 0.0% of the $353,000 rise in its health insurance.

Local earmarks FY2017–FY2025 (enacted, nine budgets) against the FY2016–FY2025 rise in health insurance
MeasureEarmarksShare of the increaseAll towns, pooled
To the city or town government$00.0%13.0%
Placed in the city or town$25,0007.1%41.2%
Everything placed$25,0007.1%45.2%

An earmark is a one-year appropriation; a health-insurance increase recurs in every later budget. Earmarks are counted on the three measures and are not adjusted for the January 2024 mid-year cuts or the FY2026 hold. All towns: pooled over the towns that reported health insurance in both years. All dollars nominal. Method.

The Commonwealth in West Tisbury

West Tisbury has 2,444 acres of mapped state conservation and recreation land and 98 acres of land coded as chapter land.

State conservation and recreation land

2,444 acres

15.3% of West Tisbury’s land

Chapter 61, 61A and 61B land

98 acres

0.6% of West Tisbury’s land · 14 parcels

Agricultural Preservation Restrictions

163 acres

state farmland program

Conservation restrictions

2,188 acres

all holders; each approved by the state

What the map shows
LayerParcelsAcres
State conservation and recreation land182,444
Other state-owned parcels (assessor records)22,433
Chapter 61A farm land1498
Partly enrolled (mixed-use parcel)19534
Agricultural Preservation Restriction9163
Conservation restriction492,188
State-owned parcels by agency (assessors’ records)
AgencyParcelsAcres
DCR State Parks and Recreation22,433
Named state conservation and recreation land
PlaceAgencyAcresArticle 97
Manuel F. Correllus State ForestDCR State Parks and Recreation2,443
West Tisbury Fire TowerDCR State Parks and Recreation2

State conservation and recreation land: MassGIS Protected and Recreational OpenSpace, land owned by a state agency, with MassGIS’s acres. State-owned parcels: assessors’ records (MassGIS standardized parcels, Commonwealth reimbursable land, codes 910–919), mapped acres; this is the land the state pays PILOT on, so it overlaps the open-space layer, and the Division of Local Services’ own acreage, above, is the official count. Chapter land: parcels coded 6, 7 and 8 (Chapter 61 forest, 61A farm, 61B recreation), taxed at their current use rather than full market value; towns code chapter land differently, and mixed-use parcels with a chapter portion are shown but not counted in the acres. Restrictions: MassGIS open space; restricted private land shows its holder, not its owner. Acres are mapped acres and may differ from deeds.

Roads: who maintains what

Of 25.0 miles of public road in West Tisbury, the state maintains 8.6 (35%); local government and others maintain the rest.

JurisdictionMilesShare
MassDOT8.635%
Town-accepted13.956%
Unaccepted public ways2.29%

Habitat, forest and water

West Tisbury has 8,642 acres of mapped core habitat, 54% of its land area; 2,988 of those acres are outside any protected land.

Land and Water Index

61 / 100113th of 351 (1 = most forest kept, most core protected, least impaired water)

Forest to 1999
24
Forest since 2001
99
Gap
71
Water
51

Rank under other weightings: 89th to 147th.

West Tisbury lost more of its 1971 forest than most towns; has kept its forest since 2001 better than most towns; has more of its core habitat on protected land than most; and a typical share of its assessed water is on the impaired list; its score of 61 stays between 89th and 147th under every weighting tested.

Core habitat (BioMap)

8,642 acres

54% of its land area · 29th of 351 · median town 25%

Core habitat on protected land

5,654 acres

65% of its core · state, federal, town, land-trust, restricted or chapter land

Forest, 1971 to 1999

-17.7%

11,155 → 9,181 acres · median town -9.7% · 261st of 351 (1 = most gained)

Assessed water impaired

66%

11 of 11 lake acres; 1.5 of 4.6 river miles · median town 67% · 168th of 351 (1 = least)

Map of the habitat, wetland and protected layers, the forest record back to 1830, and the lakes and rivers on the impaired list: West Tisbury: habitat, forest and water. All 351 on one map: habitat, forest and water, statewide.

Core habitat is BioMap (2022), the land the state’s biologists mapped as most important for rare species, intact forest, wetlands and streams. Protected land is state, federal, municipal and land-trust open space with permanent protection, land under a conservation or farmland restriction, and chapter land (the weakest of the three; it can leave the program on notice). Forest is MassGIS land use, 1971 to 1999, one method, with forested wetland counted as forest; later maps use different methods and are shown on the land page. Forest since 2001 is USGS Annual NLCD land cover, 2001 and 2023 (Collection 1). Impaired water is MassDEP’s 2022 Integrated List, assessed waters only; category 4C listings are for causes that are not pollutants, such as invasive plants. Shares are of the municipality’s land area (Census 2020).

Schools

West Tisbury’s required school contribution is 2.5% of median household income, 211th highest of 351.

Chapter 70 aid, FY2026

$1.4M

attributed to the town

Required local contribution

$5.1M

FY2026

Share of household income

2.5%

211th of 351 (1 = highest)

Real aid per pupil, FY2017–26

−1%

after inflation

West Tisbury has no school district of its own. Its pupils attend Upisland and Martha's Vineyard; West Tisbury accounts for 70% and 17% of their foundation budgets, in that order. Aid and contribution are DESE’s attribution to the town. How a region splits its assessment among members is set by its own agreement and is not published statewide.

Real figures use the CPI-U, fiscal-year average, in FY2026 dollars. The required contribution is the local share the state sets under the Chapter 70 formula; the share of income divides it per household by the town’s median household income.

School buildings

The Massachusetts School Building Authority approved grants of up to $12.8 million for schools serving West Tisbury, FY2017 to August 2026.

Approved, West Tisbury’s share

$12.8M

$4,143 per resident (18th of 351)

Projects

1

approved, July 2016 to August 2026

Statewide

$8.85B

shared by 280 of 351 municipalities

The Massachusetts School Building Authority is an independent state authority funded by one penny of the 6.25% state sales tax. Its Board approves grants for new and renovated schools (the Core program) and for roofs, windows and boilers (Accelerated Repair), and pays a share of eligible costs that rises with a community’s need. These grants are shown on their own: they are not in West Tisbury’s state money, its Fairness Index, its burden index or its peer comparisons. The Comptroller’s payment records do not carry the authority’s payments, and a single building can outweigh a decade of other state aid.

School building grants approved, newest first
YearSchoolDistrictProgramMaximum grantWest Tisbury’s share
FY2026Martha’s Vineyard Regional High SchoolMarthas VineyardCore$75.3M$12.8M (17%)

Grants to a regional district are shared among its member towns by each town’s share of the district’s enrollment (DESE, FY2026), shown in parentheses.

Amounts are the Maximum Total Facilities Grant the Board approved, a ceiling that includes contingency; the authority pays eligible costs as they are incurred and settles the final grant at audit. Year is the state fiscal year of the Board vote. Method.

Peers

West Tisbury ranks 8th of 11 on earmark dollars placed in the city or town per resident among itself and its ten nearest peers.

Peers are the ten municipalities nearest to West Tisbury on population, income need and tax-base need. The best and lowest performers are the highest and lowest on earmark dollars placed in the city or town per resident in the wider class of 30 nearest, the second of three measures.

All of the $45,000 in earmarks placed in West Tisbury went to organizations; none went to West Tisbury’s government.

MunicipalityFairness IndexFormula aid per residentCompetitive per residentEarmarks placed in the city or town, per resident (enacted)Burden indexSchool contribution, share of income
West Tisburythis town53$11,333$312$14.61†0.592.5%
Manchester-by-the-Seapeer34$6,434$696$60.012.441.6%
Sherbornpeer39$9,422$708$1090.882.7%
Doverpeer37$8,305$138$99.671.082.4%
Carlislepeer35$7,968$280$4.770.702.1%
Lincolnpeer · best in class of 3041$8,832$272$2231.391.9%
Chilmarkpeer · lowest in class of 3033$5,153$334$00.741.4%
New Marlboroughpeer49$8,719$3,098$02.062.0%
West Newburypeer48$10,655$574$38.120.912.1%
Newburypeer41$8,033$339$38.770.191.6%
Cohassetpeer32$7,092$383$129†0.762.5%
Chilmarklowest in class of 3033$5,153$334$00.741.4%

Formula aid per resident is the ten-year gross total; competitive grants are ten-year totals paid, FY2017–FY2026; earmarks are enacted clauses placed in the city or town over the same ten state budgets. † More than half of that municipality’s placed earmarks went to organizations rather than to its government. Add up to ten towns to the table; adding needs JavaScript.

Sources

Every figure traces to a public record.

Every figure on this page is built from these public sources. Method and limits.

Parcenomics helps towns turn numbers like these into a plan. Municipal services · Contact

Massanomics Weekly Every Tuesday

Your city or town, in the numbers that matter.

  • This week’s story, with where your city or town stands
  • Economics, housing and the state money that reaches you
  • Land, climate, history and politics
  • Side-by-side findings that show how it all connects
Free
every week
Sign up
One email a week. Unsubscribe from any issue.

Feedback. Every figure here is built from public records, and every claim in the report is checked against its source before it is published. The work has also been reviewed independently. If you believe something should be corrected or clarified, let us know. We will look into it promptly, and any correction is published with its date on the Method page. Provide feedback · Contact us