Commonwealth · Report
Commonwealth
Power and Politics, Money and Municipalities
19 October 2026
The report (PDF, 1.8 MB) The 351 municipalities appendix (PDF, 26.2 MB)
Contents
- SummaryEvery section’s main finding in brief, each repeated word for word at the top of its section.
- 1. What we measuredTen budgets, $93.1 billion, split into formula aid, competitive grants and earmarks, and the three ways the report counts a local earmark.
- 2. Size, not needThe size of the ask matters more than the need behind it: how the Senate treats small and large requests, and who wins the big ones.
- 3. The denominator problemWhy per resident is the wrong yardstick for infrastructure money, and what changes when grants are measured against roads, bridges and culverts.
- 4. Schools and Chapter 70The school formula delivered equity and left small and regional towns behind: Chapter 70 per pupil, regional transportation and rural aid.
- 5. Concentrated and diffuseOf 16,166 money requests, does the Senate favor money aimed at one place over money spread across many?
- 6. Why towns get what they getSize and need predict most of a town’s earmarks and grants. Power adds little, with one exception: the Senate gavel.
- 7. BreadcrumbsHouse leadership stipends, reform votes and district money: who votes for reform, who gets a paid post, and where the earmarks go.
- 8. The squeezeState aid against what towns now pay, FY2006–FY2025: health insurance, fixed costs and the 2½% levy limit.
- 9. The Fairness IndexFour ways to define a fair share, blended into one score for every town. All aid follows need; discretionary money follows size.
- 10. Case studiesThe largest earmark placed in a single town, the Pappas hospital vote, and the 35 towns with no earmark placed in them in ten state budgets.
- 11. The governor’s instrumentsNo vetoes of local earmarks in FY2025 or FY2026: how the governor uses mid-year cuts and holds instead.
- The levers and who holds themEach lever in the report and the office that can use it under existing authority.
- Methods and limitsData sources, definitions, and what the data can and cannot show.
Summary
1. What we measured
Over ten budgets, FY2017 through FY2026, the state distributed $93.1 billion through its budget to the 351 cities and towns and their school districts, counting formula aid at its gross amount; about $9.0 billion, 9.6%, was federal money passed through state appropriations. Formula aid was 97% of the total. Competitive grants came to $2.52 billion. Enacted local earmarks came to $215 million to city and town governments, $699 million placed in the city or town and $811 million counting everything placed, and every earmark figure in this report names its measure. Read more
2. Size, not need
The size of the ask matters more than the need behind it. Over ten years the Senate adopted 71% of requests under $50,000 and 6% of requests of $5 million or more. Between $1 million and $5 million, senators without a leadership post or top-tier chair won 3 of 50 need-based requests in FY2024–FY2026, against 15 of 50 for assistant leaders, whips and $30,000-tier chairs. Among need-based requests naming a town, requests for poorer resident populations were adopted less often, and requests naming the least needy towns passed 54 times in 56. Read more
3. The denominator problem
Per resident is the wrong yardstick for infrastructure money. Per resident, the smallest fifth of towns received 4.9 times their population share of competitive awards. Measured against what each program pays for, the figure is 1.47. In core infrastructure the smallest fifth as a group received 1.29 times its share and the largest fifth 0.99; the money is concentrated in a few winners, and the median small town received 0.73. Read more
4. Schools and Chapter 70
The school formula delivered equity and left small and regional towns behind. Chapter 70 aid per pupil rose 29% after inflation in cities and fell 1% in the 118 regional-member and non-operating towns. Over five years the state funded regional school transportation $65.5 million below the statutory 100%, a rate that is subject to appropriation. Rural school aid reached at best one-third of the $60 million a year the Special Commission on Rural Schools recommended in 2022. Read more
5. Concentrated and diffuse
Of 16,166 money requests filed in both chambers over ten years, 12,719 were concentrated on one place, facility or organization and 3,447 were diffuse. At the same size, the Senate adopted concentrated requests somewhat more often (odds ratio 1.40), almost all of it in requests under $250,000. The larger tilt runs through size: 38% of diffuse requests were $1 million or more, against 6% of concentrated requests, and in FY2025 and FY2026 the Senate adopted none of 39 diffuse requests of $10 million or more. Read more
6. Why towns get what they get
Size and need explain most of the variation in earmarks and competitive grants; power adds almost nothing measurable to the prediction. Size, need, capacity and local institutions predict about 56% of the cross-town variation in ten-year earmark dollars placed in the city or town and 58% in competitive grants. Adding leadership posts, stipends, loyalty, campaign giving and connections adds less than one point out of sample. Of the associations that hold, the largest is the Senate gavel: towns represented for more of the decade by the Senate President or the Senate Ways and Means chair received 86% more earmark money per standard deviation of exposure than the model expects (p < 0.001). Read more
7. Breadcrumbs
In the House, Democrats holding any paid post almost never voted the reform side: 5 of 349 member-sessions. Of House Democrats who began a session without a stipend, 62% of those who cast no reform-side vote had one by the second year, against 14% of those who voted for reform. A member’s earmark money, counted by sponsor or as earmarks to the city and town governments in the district (first measure), does not predict the vote, but among House Democrats that district money is 7.2% higher per resident for each $10,000 of the member’s stipend and 14% lower, about $2.5 million over nine budgets, for reform-side voters. On 42 members that would seem to indicate a link, and the data cannot show which way any influence runs. In the Senate, on this measure, the data would seem to indicate the opposite for reform-side voters: district money is higher for the 12 who cast one; on the wider measures neither holds. Read more
8. The squeeze
Town fixed costs are a larger pile than earmarks. From FY2016 to FY2025 municipal health insurance rose $1.43 billion, 54%, against 24.9% for nine years at 2.5%. Local earmarks in the nine budgets FY2017–FY2025 equal 13% to 45% of that increase alone, depending on the measure, and an earmark is a one-year appropriation. State aid covered 22.0% of town general-fund spending in FY2025, against 25.9% in FY2006; for the median town, 11.5% against 14.1%. Read more
9. The Fairness Index
On the Fairness Index, all state aid follows need and discretionary money follows size. The median all-aid score rises from 36 in the least needy fifth of towns to 59 in the neediest, largely through Chapter 70. On discretionary money the smallest fifth scores 91.5 at the median and the largest 36.6. Eighty-seven towns, home to 2.8 million people, stay low on both scopes under every weighting. Read more
10. Case studies
Counting everything placed, the largest clause placed in a single town in ten budgets is the FY2026 $31 million for the state-run Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children in Canton, a policy dispute over a state facility. In the same debate the Senate passed the Pappas amendment 39 to 0 and rejected, in a bundle without a vote, a $30.4 million increase in TAFDC and EAEDC cash grants. Thirty-five towns, home to 50,388 people, had no earmark placed in them in ten budgets on the second or third measure, and 33 of them rank in the top half of the state for competitive grant dollars per resident. Read more
11. The governor’s instruments
No veto of a local earmark by Governor Healey was found in FY2025 or FY2026; her instruments have been the mid-year cut and the hold. In January 2024 her 9C cuts halved local earmarks, and in FY2026 she held all $125 million of them from July 4 to October 20, 2025, then released them in full (the administration’s counts). Which earmarks survive is settled upstream, in conference, where the record does not show who decided. Read more
Massanomics Weekly Every Tuesday
Your city or town, in the numbers that matter.
- This week’s story, with where your city or town stands
- Economics, housing and the state money that reaches you
- Land, climate, history and politics
- Side-by-side findings that show how it all connects