Commonwealth · Method
How the numbers are built.
Every figure in Commonwealth is built from public records, and every method is published here so anyone can check it. Dollars carry their stage: enacted for budget earmarks, paid for Comptroller payments.
Data through FY2026; built November 9, 2026.
Terms in plain English
The report and the town pages use a few statistical terms and some budget vocabulary. Here is what each one means; on every page, the first use of a term is underlined, and hovering over it or tapping it shows the definition. Every finding is an association between numbers; none shows that one thing caused another.
- Median
- The middle value. Half the towns are above it and half below. Unlike an average, one very large city cannot pull it up or down.
- Per resident
- A town’s dollars divided by its population, so towns of different sizes can be compared.
- Smallest fifth, largest fifth
- The 351 towns ranked by population and split into five groups of about 70. The smallest fifth is the 70 or so smallest towns.
- What a town or group received divided by what an even split would give it. 1.0 is exactly its share, 2.0 is twice, 0.5 is half. The burden index is read the same way.
- The model, and “more than the model expects”
- A statistical model predicts each town’s money from facts about it: population, road miles, jobs, need, institutions. “More than the model expects” means more than towns with the same facts received.
- Log dollars
- The model compares towns by percentage differences rather than raw dollars, so a $10 million town and a $10,000 town can sit in the same analysis without the large one swamping the small one.
- R² (R-squared)
- The share of the differences between towns that a model accounts for, from 0% to 100%. “Explains about 56%” means a little more than half of the variation is accounted for and the rest is not.
- Out of sample, cross-validated
- The model is built on some towns and tested on towns it has not seen, and this is repeated until every town has been tested. It keeps a model from looking better than it is by memorizing the data. “Adds less than one point out of sample” means adding measures of legislative power raised the share explained by less than one percentage point.
- Standard deviation
- A common yardstick for how spread out a set of numbers is: roughly the typical distance from the average. “Per standard deviation of exposure” compares towns one typical step apart in how much of the decade they were represented by the Senate President or the Senate Ways and Means chair.
- p, or p-value
- How likely a pattern at least this strong would appear by chance alone if there were no real link. p < 0.001 means less than 1 chance in 1,000; p = 0.015 means about 1.5 in 100. By common convention a value under 0.05, 1 in 20, is treated as unlikely to be chance. A small p says the pattern is probably real. It does not say the pattern is large, and it does not show cause.
- 95% interval
- The range of values the data are consistent with. If the study were repeated many times, ranges built this way would contain the true value 95 times in 100.
- Odds ratio
- Compares how likely something is for one group against another. 1.0 means no difference; 1.40 means the odds are 40% higher; 0.34 means about a third as high. The report also gives the difference in percentage points.
- Percentage point
- The plain difference between two percentages. Going from 20% to 27% is 7 percentage points, which is a 35% increase.
- Rank correlation
- How closely two rankings of the towns line up, from −1 to 1. 1 means the same order, 0 means no relation, and a negative number means opposite orders.
- Controls, “at the same size,” region fixed effects
- Ways of comparing like with like. A result “at the same size” compares requests of similar size; region fixed effects compare towns only with others in the same region, so regional differences cannot produce the result.
- After inflation, real dollars
- Dollars adjusted so that different years buy the same amount. The report uses two price measures: consumer prices in the Boston area (CPI-U) and the federal price index for what state and local governments buy (wages, health insurance, construction), which has risen faster.
Budget and finance terms
- Fiscal year (FY)
- The state’s budget year, July 1 to June 30. FY2026 began July 1, 2025.
- Earmark
- A line in the state budget that sends money to a named place, project or organization. The Legislature writes it in, usually through a member’s amendment, rather than handing the money out by formula or grant competition.
- Three ways to count a local earmark
- To the city or town government: money to the city or town, its departments and schools, or a municipal project. Placed in the city or town: adds money to organizations there. Everything placed: adds state facilities there, such as a state hospital. Every earmark figure on this site says which one it uses.
- Formula aid
- State money divided among all cities and towns by a formula set in law, such as school aid and unrestricted local aid. No application is needed.
- Competitive grant
- State money a town applies for and wins in a competition run by a state agency, such as a road, building or energy grant.
- Cherry sheet
- The state’s yearly notice to each city and town of the local aid it will receive and the charges the state will deduct. It is named for the cherry-colored paper it was once printed on.
- Unrestricted local aid
- State aid a town may spend on anything in its budget. The amount is set each year in the state budget.
- Chapter 70
- The state’s main school aid program. A formula sets the least each district should spend (the foundation budget), decides how much the town must pay toward it from local taxes, and the state pays the rest.
- Foundation budget
- The least the state’s school formula says a district needs to spend for an adequate education, based on how many students it has and what they need.
- Required local contribution
- What the school formula says a town must pay toward its schools from its own taxes, based on its property values and its residents’ incomes.
- Chapter 90
- The state’s main road program. MassDOT divides it among cities and towns by formula, and each town is repaid after it spends the money on approved road work.
- School building authority (MSBA)
- The state authority that pays part of the cost of building and renovating public schools.
- PILOT on state-owned land
- A payment in lieu of taxes: state money paid to a town because state-owned land there cannot be taxed. A formula sets the amount, and it appears on the cherry sheet.
- Assessments and charges
- Amounts the state deducts from a town’s local aid, such as tuition for students who attend charter schools and payments toward regional transit.
- Proposition 2½
- The 1980 state law that limits property taxes. A town’s total tax may not exceed 2.5% of the value of all its property, and the yearly tax may rise only 2.5% plus taxes on new construction. Voters may approve an override of the yearly limit, or exclude a project’s borrowing from both limits.
- Levy limit
- The most a town may raise in property taxes in a year under Proposition 2½.
- Excess levy capacity
- The room between what a town actually raises in property taxes and the most it is allowed to raise.
- Override and debt exclusion
- A vote of the town’s residents to raise taxes above the Proposition 2½ limit, either for good (an override) or only to pay off a particular project’s borrowing (a debt exclusion).
- Free cash
- Money left over from a town’s year, once the state certifies it: mostly revenue that came in above the estimate and budgeted money not spent, less any deficits. The town can spend it only by a later vote.
- Stabilization fund
- A town’s savings fund. Money goes in and comes out by a vote of town meeting or the council.
- Consensus revenue estimate
- The tax revenue the governor’s budget office and the Legislature’s two budget chairs agree each January to expect. The next year’s budget is built on it.
- Conference committee
- Three House and three Senate members who settle the differences between the House and Senate versions of a bill, such as the budget. Both chambers then vote on their compromise as a whole, without changes.
- Mid-year cuts (9C)
- Cuts the governor may make alone during the year when revenue is expected to fall short. They reach only spending by executive agencies.
- Bond authorization
- Permission for the state to borrow and spend up to a set amount on a project. Much of it is never used: the money is spent only if the governor’s administration chooses to fund the project.
- Stipend
- Extra pay, on top of base salary, for legislators who hold leadership posts or serve as committee chairs, vice chairs or ranking minority members. The amounts are set in law.
The Fairness Index
No single definition of a fair share is right, so the index uses four and shows each one.
- Equal. Every resident counts the same. A town’s expected share is its share of the state’s population.
- Need. Each resident is weighted from 1 in the least needy towns to 3 in the neediest, using the town’s standing on poverty, median household income and tax base (equalized valuation per resident).
- Burden. Each program’s money is split by what that program pays for: road miles for road programs, pupils for school aid, road-stream crossings for culvert grants, town-owned hazard dams for dam repair, and so on. Where a town has no figure for a measure, that program is left out of its burden score rather than guessed.
- Effort. Each resident is weighted by how much the town already raises from its own residents: residential and open-space property tax (DLS assessed values and tax rates, averaged over FY2021–FY2025), less the share of homes that are seasonal, divided by residents’ income (ACS per-capita income times population). The rate is capped at the 1st and 99th percentiles.
For each lens, the town’s actual dollars are divided by what that lens would give it from the same pool of money. A ratio of 1 scores 50; half the expected amount scores 25 and twice the expected amount scores 75. To keep a very small town’s score from resting on a tiny number, every ratio is pulled slightly toward 1 by adding, to both sides, what a 250-resident town would get at the statewide rate. The headline score is the average of the four lens scores.
Chapter 70 school aid is 61% of all state aid in the index ($57.10 billion over ten years), so on all aid the four lenses mostly reflect how school aid is distributed. The discretionary score has no Chapter 70 in it.
The blend tracks the Equal lens closely. Across the 351 towns, the rank correlation between the blended score and the Equal (per resident) score is 0.98 on all aid and 0.995 on discretionary money, so a town’s blended rank is close to its per-resident rank. That is why every town page, and the table on the home page, shows the four lens scores beside the blend.
The Effort lens is shown as built. In practice the effort rate rises with median household income (rank correlation 0.24) and with school spending above the required minimum (0.37), and falls with poverty (−0.26). A town’s Effort score therefore reflects its spending choices and tax base as well as how heavily its residents are taxed.
The sensitivity range repeats the calculation under 231 weightings, with each lens between 10% and 40% in 5-point steps. A town is marked below 45 or above 55 under every weighting when its whole range sits there, between 45 and 55 when its whole range stays inside that band, and weighting-dependent when the range crosses into or out of the band.
All state aid means formula aid, competitive grants and enacted earmark clauses to the city or town government (the first of three measures), paid to the town government and its school districts. For Chapter 70 the index uses DESE’s gross aid by town, and for unrestricted aid, state-owned land, exemptions, libraries and veterans benefits it uses the cherry-sheet amounts, because the Comptroller records those payments after the state deducts charges such as charter tuition and transit assessments. Other formula programs and all competitive grants are Comptroller payments (paid). Charter and school-choice tuition are left out so they are not counted twice. Discretionary money means competitive grants and those earmarks. Because the expected amounts add up to the actual pool, the average town does not score exactly 50: a few large towns above their share are offset by many small towns below it, or the reverse.
The published scores were computed on October 21, 2026.
State money by class
Payments come from CTHRU, the Comptroller’s statewide spending data: grants and aid paid from FY2017 through FY2026, by appropriation and payee town. Each appropriation is classed as formula, competitive, earmark, shared revenue, transfer to a state entity, pass-through contract or unknown, by a written rule with the evidence recorded. About 81% of the dollars can be placed in a town. Regional school district payments are split among member towns by enrollment. Town pages show competitive grants and earmark-account payments to the town government and its school districts, the same payees as the Fairness Index; the other classes except formula are totaled in a note. Per-resident figures divide the ten-year total by residents in the American Community Survey 2020–2024.
For cherry-sheet programs, including Chapter 70 and unrestricted general government aid, CTHRU records the cash paid after the state deducts charges such as charter and school-choice tuition and transit assessments. Net figures would make charter tuition and transit assessments look like aid withheld; for Boston, ten-year Chapter 70 is $74 million net against $2.26 billion gross. Town pages and the Fairness Index therefore use gross formula aid: Chapter 70 as DESE attributes it to each town, cherry-sheet amounts for unrestricted aid, state-owned land, exemptions, libraries and veterans benefits, the special education circuit breaker from DESE, and other formula programs as paid.
CTHRU also records payments from accounts classified as earmarks. Those accounts can carry prior-year money and statewide-program money, and many enacted earmarks are paid through larger accounts, so the paid figure can be larger or smaller than the enacted clauses that name a town. Town pages show both and label each; the earmark section counts enacted budget text.
Three ways to count a local earmark
A local earmark is a “not less than” clause in an enacted budget that sends money to a particular place. This project looks at fairness by place, and there are three ways to decide which clauses belong to a town. They give different totals, so the site reports all three and labels every earmark figure with its measure.
- To the city or town government, $215 million over ten years, FY2017–FY2026. Clauses that pay the city or town government, one of its departments or schools, or a municipal project with no other recipient. Money paid to the city or town for an organization’s program counts here, because it passes through the municipal budget; money for an organization counts on the second measure, even when the organization carries the town’s name. This is the money that reaches the municipal budget, which is why the Fairness Index uses it. District money on legislator pages uses it too.
- Placed in the city or town, $699 million. Adds $485 million for organizations, whether the clause names the place or the organization’s address places it. The expected-and-actual model, the peer comparison and the list of largest items on town pages use this measure.
- Everything placed, $811 million. Adds $112 million for state facilities located in the city or town (state hospitals such as the Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children in Canton, state universities and community colleges, courts, sheriffs, state parks and beaches, the MBTA, state police) and MassHealth rate add-ons for providers there. Of that, $51.2 million is in clauses that name the city or town, such as the $4.8 million FY2026 clause for the Pocasset Mental Health Center in Bourne, a state-run inpatient psychiatric unit. The largest is the $31 million FY2026 Pappas clause.
Each measure contains the one before it, so for every town the first is no larger than the second and the second no larger than the third. All three are small beside the $5.44 billion in enacted “not less than” clauses over the ten state budgets; most of that sets floors for statewide programs. 35 municipalities had nothing placed in them on any measure.
Earmarks
An earmark is a “not less than $X shall be expended” clause in Section 2 of an enacted General Appropriations Act. The project parsed all ten enacted state budgets, FY2017 through FY2026, from the Legislature’s website: 10,040 clauses. Vetoed text that was not overridden is dropped, so every dollar shown is enacted.
A clause is placed in a town when it names the town (“city of”, “town of”, or the bare name with a false-positive filter) or when its recipient organization is based there. Clauses naming several towns are split equally. Three in four clauses can be placed in a town, but only 15% of dollars, because the largest clauses fund statewide programs. A hand check of 50 random clauses found 46 placed correctly; the other four were fixed.
Clauses that fund state facilities and MassHealth rate add-ons are identified by a written text rule (the recipient named at the head of the clause is a state hospital, university or college, court, sheriff, state park or beach, the MBTA or the state police; or the clause sets a provider rate). They count on the third measure, everything placed, and each town page shows them with their amounts.
Earmarks are counted where the money lands, not by who sponsored them. The overview lists the municipalities with no placed earmark in any of the ten state budgets.
What the town carries
Burden measures come from the agencies that keep them: local road miles from MassDOT’s Chapter 90 apportionment and Road Inventory; bridges from MassDOT and the FHWA National Bridge Inventory; road-stream crossings from the North Atlantic Aquatic Connectivity Collaborative; dams from the DCR Office of Dam Safety inventory; land and state-owned land from MassGIS; seasonal housing from the American Community Survey.
Bridges are scored, not counted. Only structures the town owns count. Each structure’s replacement cost is its deck area times the FHWA 2025 Massachusetts unit cost ($981 per square foot, or $1,306 on the National Highway System). The burden score weights that cost by condition, age and use; those weights are judgment and are stated so they can be argued with. The replacement cost does not depend on them.
- Condition, by the lowest of the deck, superstructure, substructure or culvert ratings: poor (0–4) counts 100% of replacement cost; fair (5) 50%; fair (6) 25%; good (7–9) 10%; not rated 50%.
- Age: from 0.8 for a new or rebuilt structure to 1.2 at 100 years or more.
- Use: from 0.8 to 1.2, by traffic, truck traffic, detour length and road class relative to all Massachusetts structures.
- A structure on a town line is shared equally by the towns it touches. State- and federally owned bridges, including the Cape Cod Canal bridges, never count against a town.
The burden index takes each competitive program in the award catalog, matches it to the measure it pays for (road miles for Complete Streets, crossings for culvert grants, hazard dams for dam repair, shoreline for seawalls, floodplain acres for resilience grants, housing units for Green Communities, jobs for MassWorks, cost-burdened households for housing, residents for libraries) and asks what each town would have received if the program had split its money in proportion. Actual ÷ that amount is the index; 1.0 is proportional. A second set of plausible denominators leaves the ranking close (rank correlation 0.94). Sixty-seven western towns have no digital FEMA flood map; their flood grants are left out of their index rather than guessed.
State land and growth. PILOT-eligible acres, their FY2026 valuation and the FY2026 payment in lieu of taxes come from the Division of Local Services state-owned land reports; the payment follows assessed value, so PILOT per acre (statewide $117 in FY2026) is a comparison, not the formula. The share of land area divides eligible acres by the town’s land area. New growth is the assessed value of new construction and improvements DLS certifies each year, summed FY2017–FY2025 and divided by residents (ACS 2020–2024).
The Commonwealth in the town
Each town page maps the Commonwealth’s land in the town and the state programs that shape its land, with the acres behind each layer.
- State conservation and recreation land: MassGIS Protected and Recreational OpenSpace, polygons owned by a state agency (DCR state parks and forests, DCR water supply protection, the Department of Fish and Game and others), with MassGIS’s acres. Polygons are split at town lines. Names are shown for this land only.
- Other state-owned parcels: the assessors’ records MassGIS standardizes statewide, parcels classed as Commonwealth reimbursable land (codes 910–919, by agency). This overlaps the open-space layer. The Division of Local Services’ count of state-owned acres, shown on the page with the PILOT, is the official basis of the payment; the assessors’ count can be larger, notably in reservoir watershed towns, or empty where a city’s assessor does not use the state codes.
- Chapter land: parcels classed 6 (Chapter 61 forest), 7 (Chapter 61A farm) and 8 (Chapter 61B recreation), which are taxed at their current use rather than full market value. Towns code chapter land differently. Mixed-use parcels with a chapter portion are drawn but not counted in the acres, because only part of the lot is enrolled. No owner name is fetched or shown.
- Restrictions: Agricultural Preservation Restrictions (the state’s farmland program), conservation restrictions (every one approved by the Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs) and watershed preservation restrictions, from MassGIS open space. Restricted private land shows its holder, never its owner or site name.
- Roads: MassDOT Road Inventory, public road miles by jurisdiction.
- State facilities that received earmarks: enacted clauses for state hospitals, courts, sheriffs, colleges, DCR parks and similar, placed in the city or town by address (the difference between the second and third earmark measures).
Map geometry is generalized to about 3 meters for the web; acres for assessor parcels are measured on that geometry in Massachusetts State Plane and may differ from deeds. The basemap is MassGIS’s.
What the state sends and takes back
Each town page lists every line of its FY2027 cherry sheet, the Division of Local Services’ notice of estimated state receipts (C.S. 1-ER) and of the assessments and charges the state deducts (C.S. 1-EC): county tax, mosquito control, air pollution districts, planning councils, the MBTA and regional transit, special education charges, and school choice and charter school sending tuition. Net is receipts less charges. Every town’s lines add to the sheet’s own totals. In towns that belong to a regional school district, Chapter 70 goes to the district and does not appear on the town’s sheet.
Costs and the 2½% limit
Each town page carries a panel on state aid, fixed costs and the 2½% limit. It uses the same Division of Local Services build as section 8, “The squeeze,” of the Commonwealth report (October 19, 2026), which gives the statewide figures and the full method; the panel shows one town’s line of those tables.
- Share of spending. Gross cherry-sheet state aid as entered on the tax rate recap, divided by the town’s general-fund expenditures as filed (Schedule A), for FY2006, FY2016 and FY2025. Net subtracts the charges the state assesses on the same cherry sheet (charter and school-choice tuition, transit, county and other assessments), itemized from FY2010. The median town’s share was 14.1%, 12.2% and 11.5%. A regional member’s cherry sheet carries no Chapter 70 for pupils in the regional district, while its assessment to the district is in its spending, so its share understates state support for schools; the panel says so and gives the Chapter 70 paid on its behalf.
- Against prices. FY2006 aid grown by the Boston-area CPI-U (up 55.1%) and by the federal price index for state and local government purchases (up 74.5%), fiscal-year averages, set against FY2025 aid. In FY2010 gross aid exceeded the itemized cherry sheet by $313 million statewide, consistent with school-building reimbursements that ended by FY2024; 170 town pages carry a flag where that gap was more than 2% of the town’s FY2010 aid.
- Fixed costs. Health insurance and all general-fund fixed costs, FY2016 to FY2025, against 2.5% a year (24.9% over nine years). A year is squeezed when fixed costs grew by a larger percentage than the town’s allowed levy growth (2.5% plus new growth, as a share of the prior year’s levy limit). A one-year change beyond 30% in either line is flagged on the page: such swings usually mark costs moving between budget lines, into or out of trust funds, or into the Group Insurance Commission.
- Earmarks. Enacted local earmarks in the nine budgets FY2017–FY2025, on the three measures, set against the rise in the town’s health insurance. Pooled over the 342 towns that reported health insurance in both years: 13.0%, 41.2% and 45.2%.
- Limits. Spending stops at FY2025; most towns had not filed FY2026 by October 19, 2026. Where the source has no figure, the page prints “not reported.” Dollars are nominal except in the price comparison. The figures are associations and do not measure cause.
Schools
Chapter 70 aid, foundation budgets, required local contributions and enrollment come from DESE’s Chapter 70 files, FY2017–FY2026. For towns in regional districts, aid and contribution are DESE’s attribution to the member town; how each region splits its assessment is set by its own agreement and is not published statewide. DESE town numbers are not the Department of Revenue’s town codes for 33 towns, so every DESE file is joined by town name through a checked crosswalk.
The required contribution’s share of household income divides the contribution per household by the town’s median household income (ACS 2020–2024). Real changes use the CPI-U fiscal-year average in FY2026 dollars. Real aid per pupil compares FY2017 and FY2026 attributed aid per resident pupil.
School buildings
Each town page lists the school building grants the Massachusetts School Building Authority’s Board approved for districts serving the town, from its meeting of July 20, 2016 through August 26, 2026: Core program grants for new and renovated schools, Accelerated Repair grants for roofs, windows and boilers, Board votes that raised or lowered an approved grant, and the supplemental grants the Board authorized on October 25, 2023 under the FY2024 budget. The amount is the Maximum Total Facilities Grant in the Board vote or staff memo, which includes contingency; each was checked against the authority’s press releases, and each Accelerated Repair program year reconciles to the dollar with the authority’s Overview Report of July 31, 2026.
A grant to a single-town district counts in full for that town. A grant to a regional district is shared by each member’s share of the district’s foundation enrollment in DESE’s FY2026 Chapter 70 file, applied to every year. Approvals that lapsed when local funding was not secured, or were withdrawn after approval, are named on the page and left out of every total. Final grants settled at audit are kept in the project’s data but not shown, because a project can take years to close.
The authority is funded by one penny of the 6.25% sales tax and its payments are not in the Comptroller’s CTHRU records, so these grants are not in state money, the Fairness Index, the burden index, the peer comparisons or the expected-and-actual model.
Roads, bridges and dams
Chapter 90. MassDOT’s apportionment to every city and town for state fiscal years 2017 through 2027, the annual program and each one-time supplement (the $40 million and $20 million close-out supplements, WRAP in 2022 and 2026, Fair Share in FY2024, FY2025 and the FY2026 supplemental budget, and the Rural Roadway program), from MassDOT’s published apportionment lists. Payments are every payment to a municipality on the Chapter 90 and supplement appropriations in the Comptroller’s CTHRU records through 16 October 2026. Each bond authorization is booked to its own appropriation, so each payment is tied to the year of money it drew on. “Not yet reimbursed” is apportioned money not found in the payment records; the program pays towns after they spend, and MassDOT’s Chapter 90 Advisory Group found 63% of the unspent balance committed to approved projects not yet billed (January 2025). Our unspent base balance at 31 December 2024 was $520 million; the Advisory Group reported $525 million. Years banked divide a town’s unspent annual-program money, FY2012–FY2026, by its FY2026 annual apportionment; the one-time supplements are left out of both. Months to payment run from 1 July of the apportionment year, counting each payment against the town’s oldest money first, and include the town’s own planning, bidding and construction, so they do not measure MassDOT’s processing time. Payments from other accounts are not seen: a town balance MassDOT charges for a state-administered project, or uses as a local match, appears here as not reimbursed. The FY2025 Fair Share supplement ($80 million) cannot be paid to a town out of compliance with the MBTA Communities Act; such a town’s share counts as not reimbursed. FY2027 payments are matched to appropriations by name, because CTHRU has not yet assigned their codes.
Bridges and dams. Town-owned bridges from MassDOT’s bridge inventory and the federal National Bridge Inventory; a bridge is poor when its lowest deck, superstructure, substructure or culvert rating is 4 or below. Records MassDOT keeps for a bridge since rebuilt at the same place are left out, and a bridge on a town line is listed under one town. The cost of proposed work is the state’s total project estimate in the inspection record where one is recorded (the federal inventory’s improvement-cost field, which includes approaches and engineering); for short spans outside the federal inventory, deck area times MassDOT’s median bid price for small bridges ($2,044 per square foot of new deck), with the federal replacement unit cost for Massachusetts, which prices the structure alone and runs low, shown beside it. Dams are town-owned dams in the Office of Dam Safety inventory rated high or significant hazard. Repair grants are the Dam and Seawall Repair or Removal Program, the Division of Ecological Restoration’s culvert grants, MVP action grants for dam, culvert and bridge work, and Small Bridge payments found in CTHRU; MassDOT does not publish Small Bridge award amounts. A town with no award from these programs may have used Chapter 90, local money, earmarks or federal aid instead, which these figures do not count. These counts differ from the bridge scoring behind the burden index (What the town carries) and section 3 of the report, which counts 3,771 town-owned structures, 402 of them poor, worth $5.42 billion at the unit cost, $603 million of it in the poor ones. The two use different records and prices. The burden scoring takes the 2025 inventories as published and values every structure at the unit cost, so that towns are compared on one scale; the Findings page on bridges uses MassDOT’s current inventory, drops records MassDOT keeps for bridges since rebuilt, and prices the proposed work at the state’s estimate or recent bid prices. On that basis 417 of 3,735 town-owned bridges are poor, and the work proposed for them likely comes to about $1.25 billion.
Post and district money
Each legislator page sets the member’s post and stipends for each session beside the district money for the same session (the first of the three measures, without the Ways and Means chairs’ corrective clauses, which are leadership’s money), and divides the district’s money per resident by the median district in the same chamber and session. These are associations: the table does not show that a post brought money to a district.
Expected and actual
A statewide model predicts each town’s ten-year discretionary dollars (enacted earmarks plus competitive grant payments) from factors a fair allocation could reasonably follow: population, road miles, jobs, poverty, income, tax base, Chapter 70 share, population band, the presence of hospitals, colleges and nonprofits, county seat and Gateway City status, with gross formula aid per resident as a control. These factors explain about 55–60% of the differences between towns. Earmarks in the model are placed in the city or town, the second measure; state facilities and MassHealth rate add-ons, on the third measure only, are not in it.
A town above or below its expectation is not evidence of anything improper. A single large project, a regional facility or an organization headquartered in town can put a town far from the line for ordinary reasons.
Peers
Each town’s ten peers are its nearest neighbors on standardized log population, the need score, income need and tax-base need. The wider class is the 30 nearest; the best and lowest performers in it are ranked on earmark dollars placed in the city or town per resident, the second measure. This method weights need heavily, which is why Boston’s peers should be read loosely.
Legislator pages
Each person who served in the House or Senate in the 189th through 194th General Courts, which enacted the FY2017–FY2026 budgets, has a page. A member who served in both chambers has one page. The pages carry facts only: seats, posts and stipends, the district’s money, sponsored budget amendments, bills, recorded votes and campaign receipts. No score or grade is computed, and associations are not evidence of cause.
- Seats. From the Legislature’s member records; 2011 district lines through the 192nd General Court (the FY2023 budget), 2021 lines after.
- Stipends. Additional compensation in the Comptroller’s payroll data (CTHRU 9ttk-7vz6), by calendar year, 2015–2026.
- District money. Enacted earmarks to the city and town governments in the district (the first of the three measures), by session, per resident per budget, ranked among the chamber’s districts. This is where money lands, not money attributed to the member, and leadership’s base-text money that names no place is never assigned to anyone. Clauses carried by a Ways and Means chair’s corrective amendments are counted where they name a place in the district; each page shows those dollars in their own column, with the per-resident figure and rank without them beside the main one. Each page also shows the district on the other two measures, placed in the district and everything placed, with the same per-resident ranking; those include any corrective-clause money.
- Amendments. Every amendment filed to the House and Senate budgets, FY2017–FY2026. The adoption rate is set beside the chamber’s rate for amendments of the same ask size, because small asks pass far more often than large ones. House outcomes are mostly inferred by matching amendment text to the consolidated amendments; the page says how many. Enacted items are listed when an enacted clause matches by text an amendment the member filed. Corrective and technical amendments filed in a Ways and Means chair’s name carry leadership’s money; they are shown on a separate line and left out of the chair’s own counts, asks, adoption rate and items.
- Bills. Every bill and resolve a member filed as lead sponsor, with the furthest point it reached in the bill history. Documents filed in a member’s name as a committee chair or presiding officer (committee new drafts and substitutions, which carry no docket number, budgets, further and corrective amendments, and special-election precepts) are listed apart and not counted as the member’s own bills, on the same principle as the Ways and Means corrective amendments. A folded bill that landed in the same chapter as another of the member’s enacted bills is counted once. Where a bill or amendment title names a private individual (a sick leave bank, a pension, creditable service, continued employment, a civil-service waiver, relief, an estate or a land conveyance), the name is replaced with “a state employee,” “an employee of” the department the title names, the role the title gives, or “an individual.” Titles that commemorate a person, and public officials named in their official capacity, are shown as filed.
- Votes. Selected roll calls on the Legislature’s own rules, audits, public records, term limits and pay, with the project’s plain description of each question (for rules-package roll calls, the question as recorded). The headline counts yes and no votes; not voting and present are shown apart. Rules-package adoptions and public-records passage votes are marked “contested meaning” because reform advocates were on both sides.
- Campaign money. Total contributions count every contribution of any size to the member’s own candidate committee reported to the Office of Campaign and Political Finance since January 1, 2015, when the compilation begins, including small receipts the committee reported only as an aggregate total; the same exclusions and refund netting apply as below. Totals are shown for the current cycle (2025–26, through the reports filed by October 21, 2026), the last cycle (2023–24) and the years the member served since 2015. Ranks compare members serving now in the same chamber, on contributions this cycle and on cash on hand, the committee’s balance at its latest bank report (OCPF’s legislative year-to-date summary). Itemized reports can trail the bank reports; where a committee’s itemized receipts for 2026 are more than 10% below its bank-reported receipts, its page says so. Who gave: each giver’s contributions to the member’s committee in a two-year cycle are added together (an individual matched on name and five-digit ZIP code, an organization on its OCPF id or name) and the giver is placed in a band by that total; gifts from people who gave $50 or less in a year that the committee reported only as a total are shown as at least that total divided by $50 givers. Where the givers live: each giver’s street address on their latest gift in the cycle was placed on the map with the Census Bureau’s geocoder and tested against the member’s current district (Census TIGER/Line 2023 state legislative districts); about 92% of Massachusetts addresses were placed, and the rest are reported as not matched. Addresses and names are used only for this test and are not published. The detail by kind of contributor, employer and organization uses itemized receipts of $250 or more, grouped by the contributor’s employer or organization. Contributions are receipts from individuals, committees and PACs, and unions and associations; candidate loans, transfers between a committee’s own accounts, refunds and reimbursements received, interest and aggregated small receipts are reported on a separate line, and so are receipts filed as contributions that are one of these, or come from the filer’s own committee. A contribution the committee later refunded is netted against the refund, matched on payer and committee from the committee’s refund expenditures or the receipt’s own refund note. An organization that is evidently a business or a foreign government but was filed as a PAC or a union is shown as such, with the type it was filed under. Employer fields that are a job title or a bookkeeping note are counted as not reported. The statewide officers’ and Governor’s Councillors’ pages use the same measures for their own candidate committees, with cash on hand from OCPF’s statewide and county year-to-date summaries; their givers are counted over the same two-year periods as the legislators’; councillors’ givers are tested against the 2021 councillor districts (MassGIS), each made of five Senate districts; their pay is from the Comptroller’s payroll data. No individual contributor is named.
Habitat, forest and water
Each municipality’s page has a card on its land and water, and a longer page of its own at habitat, forest and water. The figures come from state map layers, read by script and clipped to municipal boundaries; shares are of the municipality’s land area (Census 2020), not its water.
- Core habitat is BioMap (2022): the land the state’s biologists mapped as most important for rare species, intact forest, wetlands and streams. Critical natural landscape is BioMap’s wider layer of large intact blocks and buffers. The two overlap and are never added.
- Protected land is open space of any owner (state, federal, municipal, land trust or nonprofit) with permanent protection in the state’s open-space inventory, state-owned open space at any protection level, land under a conservation, farmland or watershed restriction, and land enrolled in the chapter 61, 61A and 61B tax programs. Chapter land is the weakest of these: an owner can withdraw it on notice. It is about a tenth of the protected core acres statewide; leaving it out would move 116 municipalities more than ten places in the index.
- Wetlands are MassDEP’s 1:12,000 wetlands layer. Ponds and other open water are shown on the maps but counted on their own line, so the wetland figure matches MassDEP’s published statewide total.
- Forest is MassGIS land use for 1971, 1985 and 1999, one method throughout, with forested wetland counted as forest. The 2005 land-use map and DCR’s 2021 satellite estimate were made differently and are shown as separate points, never compared with the series.
- Impaired water means a lake or river segment that MassDEP’s 2022 Integrated List places in categories 4A, 4C or 5: assessed and found not to meet its standard for at least one use. Only assessed waters count; most small ponds and brooks are not assessed. Category 4C is for causes that are not pollutants, such as invasive plants.
- The 1830 map is the woodland each town drew on its 1830 survey map, digitized by Harvard Forest and MassGIS. Maps survive for 299 of the 351; the others say so. The maps under-record small woodlots, so the 1830 figure is a floor.
- The forest mix before settlement is the trees surveyors recorded at lot corners and along roads when a town was laid out, compiled by Harvard Forest; 164 municipalities have a record of their own. Today’s mix is U.S. Forest Service inventory plots pooled by county, because single-town plot counts are too small to stand alone.
The Land and Water Index
The index is the average of four lenses. Each lens places the municipality among the 351 as a percentile, so the median municipality scores 50 on each lens and a score of 75 means three-quarters of municipalities sit below it. The index describes what has happened to a municipality’s land and water; it is not a measure of its conduct or effort.
- Forest to 1999: forest acres in 1999 against 1971. A municipality that kept more of its 1971 forest than most scores above 50.
- Forest since 2001: forest acres in 2023 against 2001, from USGS Annual NLCD land cover (Collection 1), one method throughout; forest and woody wetland, as the state series counts forested wetland. A municipality that kept or regained more of its forest than most scores above 50. The two forest lenses use different sources and are not joined into one series.
- Gap: the share of its core habitat that sits on protected land, as defined above. More of its core protected means a higher score.
- Water: the share of its assessed lake acres and river miles on the impaired list, the two averaged where both exist. Waters whose only listing is mercury in fish tissue are left out, because that mercury arrives from the air and says nothing about local land use. Less impaired water means a higher score.
A lens is left blank where it cannot apply: under 100 acres of forest in 1971, under 100 acres of forest in 2001, under 100 acres of core habitat, or no assessed water. A municipality is scored on the lenses it has, and not scored at all with fewer than two; seven are not scored. Ties share the average place. The rank range on each page comes from recomputing the index nine times: at equal weights and with each lens in turn counted double or half. “Stable high” means the index stayed at 55 or above in all nine; “stable low” means 45 or below in all nine.
Municipalities with fewer people per square mile tend to score higher: about 46% of the ranking follows population density, mostly through the forest-to-1999 lens (dense places had little forest left to lose by 1971) and partly through the forest-since-2001 and water lenses; the protected-habitat lens barely relates to density. Municipalities of similar density still span a wide range of scores, so each page also gives the rank among the 70 or so municipalities in the same fifth of the density range.
Every figure was recomputed by a second, independent pass from the same public sources before publication, and the method text was corrected where that pass found it unclear.
Limits
- Earmark dollars are enacted text, not payments. A held or unspent earmark counts in full.
- Payments are placed by payee town. A payment to a regional body or a statewide organization is placed where the payee is, or not placed at all.
- Population is a single ACS 2020–2024 value for all ten years.
- Representation shows current members and 2021 district lines. Earlier years used the 2011 lines.
- Where a value is missing, the page says “not available.” Nothing missing is shown as zero.
Corrections
Each correction to a published figure is listed here with its date. Feedback that leads to a correction is welcome through the form at the foot of every page.
- October 21, 2026. The first way of counting local earmarks now counts only money to the city or town government: the government itself, its departments and schools, and municipal projects with no other recipient. It had counted every clause that named a town, including organizations named with the town (the Gloucester Marine Genomics Institute, for example), state facilities (the Pocasset Mental Health Center in Bourne), state parks and beaches, and state agency programs. Organizations now count on the second measure; state facilities, named state parks and beaches and state agency programs on the third. Who was paid is taken from the Comptroller’s payment records where they show it, and otherwise from the clause text, read clause by clause where it is unclear. Where the payment records show money paid to the city or town for an organization’s program, it counts on the first measure, because it passes through the municipal budget. The first measure fell from $485 million to $215 million over ten years, and the second from $718 million to $699 million; the third is unchanged at $811 million. The Fairness Index, district money on legislator pages, town pages and the report were recomputed. The House district-money results keep their direction. The Senate results on the first measure changed: the data would seem to indicate that district money rises with the stipend and is higher for the 12 senators who cast a reform-side vote; on the wider measures neither holds. The measures were renamed: to the city or town government, placed in the city or town, everything placed.
Sources
- MassGIS Protected and Recreational OpenSpace
- MassGIS Standardized Assessor Parcels
- MassGIS-MassDOT Roads (Road Inventory)
- Division of Local Services, FY2027 cherry sheets
- CTHRU statewide spending, Office of the Comptroller
- General Appropriations Acts, enacted text
- Division of Local Services, assessed values and tax rates
- DESE Chapter 70 aid by town (gross)
- American Community Survey 2020–2024, U.S. Census Bureau
- Massachusetts Legislature, members and districts
- District lines: Acts of 2021, chapters 82 and 83; Census 2020 block populations
- DESE school district profiles and enrollment
- MassGIS regional planning agencies
- MassDOT Chapter 90 apportionment and Road Inventory
- FHWA National Bridge Inventory, 2025
- MassDOT Bridges layer (GeoDOT)
- North Atlantic Aquatic Connectivity Collaborative, road-stream crossings
- DCR Office of Dam Safety inventory, via MassGIS
- State grant award lists (Community One Stop, MVP, Green Communities and others)
- DLS Databank, state-owned land eligible for PILOT
- DLS Databank, new growth
- DLS Databank, Schedule A general fund expenditures and revenues
- DLS Databank, health insurance expenditures
- DLS Databank, revenue by source (state aid)
- DLS Databank, cherry sheet receipts and charges by program
- Boston-area CPI-U (BLS) and state-local price index (BEA), via FRED
- Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI-U
- Massachusetts School Building Authority, Board meeting memos, votes and minutes
- Massachusetts School Building Authority, grant announcements
Massanomics Weekly Every Tuesday
Your city or town, in the numbers that matter.
- This week’s story, with where your city or town stands
- Economics, housing and the state money that reaches you
- Land, climate, history and politics
- Side-by-side findings that show how it all connects