Commonwealth · For policymakers · Dukes County
Understanding and planning for Tisbury’s future
The figures for Tisbury from its own pages on this site, in three paths. Each is quoted as it appears there and links back to it.
Tisbury on the site: front page · state money · land and water · all towns · FEMA and MEMA
Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats in Tisbury’s record
Every line below is produced by a rule that is written once and applied to all 351 cities and towns. A line is published only when the figure it cites is printed on the page it links to. Strengths and weaknesses compare Tisbury with its ten nearest peers (the best or worst quarter, and past the peers’ median) or, where peers do not apply, with the quarters of all towns. Opportunities name programs the town can act on alone. There is no score and no ranking of danger.
Strengths (9)
Where the record is in the best quarter of the town and its peers, or statewide.
Free cash 13.3% of the budget, FY2026 (DLS). Rank 3 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
New growth, the assessed value of new construction and improvements added to the tax base, came to $66,260 per resident over FY2017–FY2025. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Equalized valuation per resident $1,093,493, 2024 (DOR). Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Figures behind the finance lines, Equalized valuation per resident
Poverty rate 7.1% (ACS 2020–24). Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
The town government and its school districts received $6,847 per resident in formula aid, FY2017–26, 297th of 351. Rank 3 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Chapter 70 aid per pupil changed +38% after inflation from FY2017 to FY2026. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
School-building grants approved for the schools serving the town come to $3,328 per resident, FY2017 to August 2026, 41st of 351. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
2.0 miles of public road in the FEMA 1% flood zone, 8.0% of 24.7 public road miles. Rank 2 of 7 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Flood insurance: since 1978, 36 claim records for Tisbury, 23 of them with a payment, $276,864 paid in all (7 records and $19,829 paid since 2010). Policies in force on December 31, 2025: 143. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Weaknesses (9)
Where the record is in the worst quarter of the town and its peers, or statewide.
Fixed costs grew faster than allowed levy growth in 6 of the 9 years FY2017–25. Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Debt service 16.3% of general-fund spending, FY2024 (DLS). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Average single-family tax bill 40.8% of income per capita, FY2026 (DLS). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Figures behind the finance lines, Average single-family tax bill
Median household income is $74,000. Rank 10 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Owners 65 and older paying 30% or more of income on owner costs 51% (ACS 2020–24). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Figures behind the finance lines, Owners 65 and older, cost burden
The required school contribution is 5.5% of median household income. Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
38% of the town’s mapped core habitat, 332 of 862 acres, is on protected land. Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Open releases in Tisbury: 6, or 1.43 per 1,000 acres, in the highest quarter of the town and its ten nearest peers (peer median 0.31). MassDEP’s release list shows 77 releases in Tisbury, as of September 30, 2026: 6 open, 60 closed and 11 with another status. A site count is not a measure of current risk.
Earmarks to the town government came to $0 over the nine budgets FY2017–25 (the page’s health-insurance comparison). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best.
Opportunities (7)
Programs the town can apply for or adopt on its own, and the trigger in its record.
Your record matches culvert replacement and Municipal Vulnerability Preparedness (MVP) action grants because 2.0 of 24.7 public road miles are in the FEMA 1% flood zone, in the top quarter of towns with a digital map.
Your record matches FEMA Community Rating System because 143 flood insurance policies were in force on December 31, 2025, in the top quarter of towns.
Your record matches local-option room occupancy and short-term rental taxes because 39% of its housing units are seasonal, in the top quarter of towns.
Your record matches health-plan design under the municipal health insurance reform law because fixed costs outgrew allowed levy growth in 6 of 9 years, in the worst quarter of its peers.
Your record matches drawing down Chapter 90 on completed projects because 7.2 years of its yearly Chapter 90 money are not yet reimbursed, in the top quarter of towns.
Your record matches brownfields assessment and cleanup grants: MassDevelopment and EPA because MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open Tier I or II release in Tisbury, as of September 30, 2026; the list shows 77 releases in total, 6 open, 60 closed and 11 with another status. EPA’s records list no brownfields grant made directly to the town or its redevelopment body; regional coalition grants are not split among towns. A site count is not a measure of current risk.
Figures behind the lines, Releases on MassDEP’s release list
Your record matches state PFAS funding for water systems through the Clean Water Trust and the State Revolving Fund because MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open cleanup site in Tisbury where PFAS is a listed contaminant, as of September 30, 2026 (a floor).
Threats (3)
Weaknesses past a stated line, published risk records, or state condition ratings.
Fixed costs grew faster than allowed levy growth in 6 of the 9 years FY2017–25, a majority of years.
MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open cleanup site in Tisbury where PFAS is a listed contaminant, as of September 30, 2026. The list records contaminants named at notification, so this is a floor.
2.0 miles of public road in the FEMA 1% flood zone, 8.0% of 24.7 public road miles. Top quarter statewide of the towns with a digital flood map.
For your delegation
These levers are set in law or run by a state agency, so they sit with your state representative and senator. Each names the trigger in Tisbury’s record.
Your record matches the Chapter 70 formulas, which are set in law, because the required school contribution is 5.5% of median household income, in the worst quarter of its peers.
Your record matches FEMA appeals and state disaster aid because Dukes County was named in a Commonwealth request that FEMA denied (see the table of requests).
Your record matches budget amendments and earmark requests because earmarks to the town government came to $0, against a median of $15.71 per resident among its ten nearest peers.
Budget season
What the state sends and takes back, and how the town compares with its peers.
- Fairness Index
Tisbury scores 27 on the Fairness Index for all state aid and 48 for discretionary money. Fifty is a fair share.
- State money
Tisbury’s town government and school districts received $33.5 million in formula aid and $2.2 million in competitive grants over ten years.
- Aid and charges
In FY2027 the state’s cherry sheet sends Tisbury $2.1 million and takes back $1.6 million in assessments and charges, a net $451,000.
- Earmarks
No local earmark was placed in Tisbury in ten enacted state budgets, FY2017 to FY2026, on any of the three measures.
- Peers
Tisbury is the only municipality, among itself and its ten nearest peers, with no earmarks placed in it in the ten state budgets.
- Costs and the 2½% limit
State aid covered 4.8% of Tisbury’s general-fund spending in FY2025, down from 5.4% in FY2006.
Capital and hazard planning
Dams, flood-zone roads, water sources, fire and low-water records.
- Public roads and facilities in the FEMA flood zone
2.0 of 24.7 public road miles are in the FEMA 1% flood zone (1.0 town-accepted, 1.0 MassDOT).
Named public facilities in the 1% zone: none among the mapped schools, police and fire stations, town and city halls, libraries, hospitals and wastewater plants.
- Scour-critical bridges
None coded 0 to 3 on the federal inventory’s scour item.
- Dams
No High or Significant hazard dams are listed in Tisbury.
- Public water sources
Tisbury has five active community-system sources located in the town: five groundwater and no surface water.
- Low water
Tisbury is in the Islands drought region.
Periods at the highest level of each plan (Warning, Critical):
No USGS stream gauge with a long record lies within 15 miles of Tisbury, so no low-flow strip is shown.
- Fire
Tisbury had 12 recorded fires, burning 2.25 acres, in 2015–2024 in the federal Fire Occurrence Database.
- Where the records meet
Where the records meet lists Tisbury on 1 of 4 town-level records and 0 of 2 county or region records. A count of lists is not a measure of severity, likelihood or preparedness.
Record Value Listing Roads in the FEMA flood zone
% of public road miles, town8.03% listed Dams
High or Significant dams rated Poor or Unsatisfactory, town0 not listed Drought
months in drought region, 2019 to 202618 mo. not listed Fire
fires per sq. mi., 2015 to 2024, town1.84 not listed Power outages
customer-hours per housing unit, county, 2021 to 202527.4 h not listed Flood-insurance claims
paid per housing unit, 2009 on, town$5.79 not listed
Disaster readiness
Hazard mitigation plan status and federal aid to the town government.
- Hazard mitigation plan
Awaiting revisions (FEMA). Plan: Dukes County Multi-Jurisdiction Hazard Mitigation Plan Update 2026.
- Public Assistance
FEMA has obligated $92,371 in federal share to the Tisbury town government, across 10 funded projects in 6 disasters (declarations from December 1999 on). These are obligations to date, not spending. Fire districts, light plants, schools and other local units are separate and not counted.
- Hazard mitigation grants
The Tisbury town government filed three subapplications; one has funds obligated to date, totaling $78,750 in federal share.
- Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities: 1 subapplication, 1 with funds obligated to date, $78,750 obligated
- Flood Mitigation Assistance: 1 subapplication, 0 with funds obligated to date, $0 obligated
- Pre-Disaster Mitigation: 1 subapplication, 0 with funds obligated to date, $0 obligated
- Flood insurance claims
Since 1978, 36 claim records for Tisbury, 23 of them with a payment, $276,864 paid in all (7 records and $19,829 paid since 2010). Policies in force on December 31, 2025: 143.
- Federal declarations
Since 1953, 26 federal declarations have designated Dukes County, counting statewide declarations.
Figures behind the lines
No other page on this site prints these figures, so they are printed here, each with its year or as-of date and its source. Senior property tax work-off and clause-by-clause exemptions are not in these records, so no line says whether the town has them.
- Excess levy capacity
- Excess levy capacity 0.1% of the maximum levy limit, FY2026 (DLS)
- Free cash
- Free cash 13.3% of the budget, FY2026 (DLS)
- Stabilization funds
- Stabilization funds 11.9% of the budget, FY2025 (DLS)
- Debt service
- Debt service 16.3% of general-fund spending, FY2024 (DLS)
- Commercial, industrial and personal property
- Commercial, industrial and personal property 8.2% of assessed value, FY2026 (DLS)
- Equalized valuation per resident
- Equalized valuation per resident $1,093,493, 2024 (DOR)
- Average single-family tax bill
- Average single-family tax bill 40.8% of income per capita, FY2026 (DLS)
- Residential tax rate
- Residential tax rate $7.42 per $1,000, FY2026 (DLS)
- Poverty rate
- Poverty rate 7.1% (ACS 2020–24)
- Owners 65 and older
- Owner households with a householder 65 or older 38% (ACS 2020–24)
- Median home value
- Median home value $993,600 (ACS 2020–24)
- Income, households 65 and older
- Median income of households 65 and older $71,000 (ACS 2020–24)
- Owners 65 and older, cost burden
- Owners 65 and older paying 30% or more of income on owner costs 51% (ACS 2020–24)
- Property tax deferrals
- Deferrals outstanding: $3,408 (DLS)
- Community Preservation Act
- Community Preservation Act adopted 2006 at 3% (DLS Local Options)
- Senior means-tested exemption
- Means-tested senior exemption not adopted (DLS Local Options)
- Small commercial exemption
- Small commercial exemption not adopted (DLS Local Options)
- Residential exemption
- Residential exemption adopted at 22% (DLS Local Options)
- Tax rate type
- Tax rate type single, FY2026 (DLS)
- Releases on MassDEP’s release list
- MassDEP’s release list shows 77 releases in Tisbury, as of September 30, 2026: 6 open, 60 closed and 11 with another status. Of the 6 open, 1 are Tier I or II and 5 are Tier ID. A site count is not a measure of current risk. Many are closed cleanups or small heating-oil releases, and towns with more businesses record more. Default status (Tier ID) means a required filing was late. It is not a finding about the site’s contamination.
- Open releases per 1,000 acres
- Open releases in Tisbury: 6, or 1.43 per 1,000 acres (4,206 acres, total area within the town’s survey boundaries, including inland water) and 1.23 per 1,000 residents (ACS 2020–24 population). Open means status Tier I, Tier II, Tier ID, TMPS, REMOPS, TCLASS or UNCLSS on MassDEP’s release list, as of September 30, 2026.
- EPA brownfields grants
- EPA’s brownfields grant records (ACRES) list no grant made directly to Tisbury or its redevelopment body. Regional coalition grants are not split among towns. Source: EPA ACRES, pulled November 9, 2026.
- PFAS in open cleanup sites
- MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open cleanup site in Tisbury where PFAS is a listed contaminant, as of September 30, 2026. The list records contaminants named at notification, so this is a floor. Statewide, 36 cleanup sites where PFAS is a listed contaminant carry a status code MassDEP does not define in its published code table; they are counted as other, not open.
All lines for Tisbury (31)
| Box | Line | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Strength | Free cash 13.3% of the budget, FY2026 (DLS). Rank 3 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Figures behind the finance lines, Free cash |
| Strength | New growth, the assessed value of new construction and improvements added to the tax base, came to $66,260 per resident over FY2017–FY2025. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, What the town carries |
| Strength | Equalized valuation per resident $1,093,493, 2024 (DOR). Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Figures behind the finance lines, Equalized valuation per resident |
| Strength | Poverty rate 7.1% (ACS 2020–24). Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Figures behind the finance lines, Poverty rate |
| Strength | The town government and its school districts received $6,847 per resident in formula aid, FY2017–26, 297th of 351. Rank 3 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, State money |
| Strength | Chapter 70 aid per pupil changed +38% after inflation from FY2017 to FY2026. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, Schools |
| Strength | School-building grants approved for the schools serving the town come to $3,328 per resident, FY2017 to August 2026, 41st of 351. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, School buildings |
| Strength | 2.0 miles of public road in the FEMA 1% flood zone, 8.0% of 24.7 public road miles. Rank 2 of 7 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Land and water page, Public assets in mapped hazard areas |
| Strength | Flood insurance: since 1978, 36 claim records for Tisbury, 23 of them with a payment, $276,864 paid in all (7 records and $19,829 paid since 2010). Policies in force on December 31, 2025: 143. Rank 2 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Land and water page, Federal disaster declarations and aid |
| Weakness | Fixed costs grew faster than allowed levy growth in 6 of the 9 years FY2017–25. Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, Costs and the 2½% limit |
| Weakness | Debt service 16.3% of general-fund spending, FY2024 (DLS). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Figures behind the finance lines, Debt service |
| Weakness | Average single-family tax bill 40.8% of income per capita, FY2026 (DLS). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Figures behind the finance lines, Average single-family tax bill |
| Weakness | Median household income is $74,000. Rank 10 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, In brief |
| Weakness | Owners 65 and older paying 30% or more of income on owner costs 51% (ACS 2020–24). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | Figures behind the finance lines, Owners 65 and older, cost burden |
| Weakness | The required school contribution is 5.5% of median household income. Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, Schools |
| Weakness | 38% of the town’s mapped core habitat, 332 of 862 acres, is on protected land. Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, Habitat and water |
| Weakness | Open releases in Tisbury: 6, or 1.43 per 1,000 acres, in the highest quarter of the town and its ten nearest peers (peer median 0.31). MassDEP’s release list shows 77 releases in Tisbury, as of September 30, 2026: 6 open, 60 closed and 11 with another status. A site count is not a measure of current risk. | Figures behind the lines, Open releases per 1,000 acres |
| Weakness | Earmarks to the town government came to $0 over the nine budgets FY2017–25 (the page’s health-insurance comparison). Rank 11 of 11 among the town and its ten nearest peers, where 1 is best. | State money page, Costs and the 2½% limit |
| Opportunity | Your record matches culvert replacement and Municipal Vulnerability Preparedness (MVP) action grants because 2.0 of 24.7 public road miles are in the FEMA 1% flood zone, in the top quarter of towns with a digital map. | Land and water page, Public assets in mapped hazard areas |
| Opportunity | Your record matches FEMA Community Rating System because 143 flood insurance policies were in force on December 31, 2025, in the top quarter of towns. | Land and water page, Federal disaster declarations and aid |
| Opportunity | Your record matches local-option room occupancy and short-term rental taxes because 39% of its housing units are seasonal, in the top quarter of towns. | State money page, What the town carries |
| Opportunity | Your record matches health-plan design under the municipal health insurance reform law because fixed costs outgrew allowed levy growth in 6 of 9 years, in the worst quarter of its peers. | State money page, Costs and the 2½% limit |
| Opportunity | Your record matches drawing down Chapter 90 on completed projects because 7.2 years of its yearly Chapter 90 money are not yet reimbursed, in the top quarter of towns. | State money page, Roads and bridges |
| Opportunity | Your record matches brownfields assessment and cleanup grants: MassDevelopment and EPA because MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open Tier I or II release in Tisbury, as of September 30, 2026; the list shows 77 releases in total, 6 open, 60 closed and 11 with another status. EPA’s records list no brownfields grant made directly to the town or its redevelopment body; regional coalition grants are not split among towns. A site count is not a measure of current risk. | Figures behind the lines, Releases on MassDEP’s release list |
| Opportunity | Your record matches state PFAS funding for water systems through the Clean Water Trust and the State Revolving Fund because MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open cleanup site in Tisbury where PFAS is a listed contaminant, as of September 30, 2026 (a floor). | Figures behind the lines, PFAS in open cleanup sites |
| Threat | Fixed costs grew faster than allowed levy growth in 6 of the 9 years FY2017–25, a majority of years. | State money page, Costs and the 2½% limit |
| Threat | MassDEP’s release list shows 1 open cleanup site in Tisbury where PFAS is a listed contaminant, as of September 30, 2026. The list records contaminants named at notification, so this is a floor. | Figures behind the lines, PFAS in open cleanup sites |
| Threat | 2.0 miles of public road in the FEMA 1% flood zone, 8.0% of 24.7 public road miles. Top quarter statewide of the towns with a digital flood map. | Land and water page, Public assets in mapped hazard areas |
| Delegation | Your record matches the Chapter 70 formulas, which are set in law, because the required school contribution is 5.5% of median household income, in the worst quarter of its peers. | State money page, Schools |
| Delegation | Your record matches FEMA appeals and state disaster aid because Dukes County was named in a Commonwealth request that FEMA denied (see the table of requests). | FEMA and MEMA page, Requests and outcomes |
| Delegation | Your record matches budget amendments and earmark requests because earmarks to the town government came to $0, against a median of $15.71 per resident among its ten nearest peers. | State money page, Costs and the 2½% limit |
Contact
Start a conversation
Tell us what you’re working on and we’ll help with whatever you need.
We present and consult for executive agencies, the Legislature and municipalities alike.