Dukes County · History
The history of Edgartown
Settled 1642 · incorporated 1671
Dates from the State Library of Massachusetts, “Cities and Towns of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts at 250,” which cites the Secretary of the Commonwealth. We read the page by machine and have not yet checked each date against it.
Population
How many people lived in Edgartown
Edgartown counted 944 people in 1765 and 5,168 in 2020.
Federal censusState census or provincial count
No accepted figure yet for 1910 and 1920.
- 1671: Established July 8, 1671 (N.
- 1830: And the said Towne which for the future shall bee called by the name of Edgar Towne." Boundary line between Edgartown and Tisbury established February 5, 1830, and April 23, 1862.
- 1880: Part of the town set off as the new town Cottage City February 17, 1880.
The figures, where each comes from, and more notes
| Year | People | Kind | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1765 | 944 | Provincial count | A |
| 1776 | 1,020 | Provincial count | B |
| 1790 | 1,352 | Federal census | C |
| 1800 | 1,226 | Federal census | D |
| 1810 | 1,365 | Federal census | E |
| 1820 | 1,374 | Federal census | F |
| 1830 | 1,509 | Federal census | G |
| 1840 | 1,736 | Federal census | H |
| 1850 | 1,990 | Federal census | I |
| 1855 | 1,898 | State census | J |
| 1860 | 2,118 | Federal census | K |
| 1865 | 1,846 | State census | L |
| 1870 | 1,516 | Federal census | M |
| 1875 | 1,707 | State census | N |
| 1880 | 1,303 | Federal census | O |
| 1885 | 1,165 | State census | P |
| 1890 | 1,156 | Federal census | Q |
| 1895 | 1,125 | State census | R |
| 1900 | 1,209 | Federal census | S |
| 1905 | 1,175 | State census | T |
| 1915 | 1,276 | State census | U |
| 1930 | 1,276 | Federal census | V |
| 1940 | 1,370 | Federal census | W |
| 1950 | 1,508 | Federal census | X |
| 1960 | 1,474 | Federal census | Y |
| 1970 | 1,481 | Federal census | Z |
| 1980 | 2,204 | Federal census | 26 |
| 1990 | 3,062 | Federal census | 27 |
| 2000 | 3,779 | Federal census | 28 |
| 2010 | 4,067 | Federal census | 29 |
| 2020 | 5,168 | Federal census | 30 |
- A. 1765 provincial census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1765 reproduced exactly by town values
- B. 1776 provincial census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1776 reproduced exactly by town values
- C. 1790 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1790 reproduced exactly by town values
- D. 1800 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1800 reproduced exactly by town values
- E. 1810 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1810 reproduced exactly by town values
- F. 1820 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1820 reproduced exactly by town values
- G. 1830 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1830 reproduced exactly by town values
- H. 1840 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1840 reproduced exactly by town values
- I. 1850 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1850 reproduced exactly by town values
- J. 1855 state census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1855 reproduced exactly by town values
- K. 1860 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1860 reproduced exactly by town values
- L. 1865 state census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1865 reproduced exactly by town values
- M. 1870 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1870 reproduced exactly by town values
- N. 1875 state census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1875 reproduced exactly by town values
- O. 1880 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1880 reproduced exactly by town values
- P. 1885 state census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1885 reproduced exactly by town values
- Q. 1890 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1890 reproduced exactly by town values
- R. 1895 state census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1895 reproduced exactly by town values
- S. 1900 US census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, county total for Dukes 1900 reproduced exactly by town values
- T. 1905 state census as printed in Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905 Vol. I p. 832, confirmed by 1915 state census Vol. Table 2 (1905 column)
- U. 1915 state census, Decennial Census of the Commonwealth 1915, Table 2 p. 50; county total for Dukes reproduced exactly (Table 1 Recapitulation p. 48)
- V. 1930 US census as printed in 1950 Census Vol. I Ch. 24 (Massachusetts) Table 6; county total reproduced exactly by town values; scan page images in work/ocr/pages (page number per cell not recorded)
- W. 1940 US census as printed in 1960 Census of Population Vol. I Part 23 Table 7, confirmed by 1950 Census Vol. I Ch. 24 Table 6; county total reproduced exactly by town values; scan page images in work/ocr/pages (page number per cell not recorded)
- X. 1950 US census as printed in 1960 Census of Population Vol. I Part 23 Table 7, confirmed by 1950 Census Vol. I Ch. 24 Table 6; county total reproduced exactly by town values; scan page images in work/ocr/pages (page number per cell not recorded)
- Y. 1960 US census, Census of Population Vol. I Part 23 (Massachusetts) Table 7; county total reproduced exactly by town values; scan page images in work/ocr/pages (page number per cell not recorded)
- Z. 1970 Census figure as printed in 1990 CPH-2-23 Table 8 (pdf line 1057); "r" revision flags dropped
- 26. 1980 Census figure as printed in 1990 CPH-2-23 Table 8 (pdf line 1057); "r" revision flags dropped
- 27. 1990 Census figure as printed in 1990 CPH-2-23 Table 8 (pdf line 1057); "r" revision flags dropped
- 28. 2000 Census PL 94-171 P001001 (mageo.upl, ma00001.upl)
- 29. 2010 Census PL 94-171 P0010001 (mageo2010.pl, ma000012010.pl)
- 30. 2020 Census PL 94-171 P1_001N (mageo2020.pl, ma000012020.pl)
Boundary and establishment notes
- Book of Patents, Vol.
- IV, p. 75). "The said Towne being formerly known by the name of Great Harbour . . .
Town boundaries changed over these years; each figure is for the town as that census counted it. A missing year is left blank, not estimated.
Counted separately
People the census counted apart
The 1905 state census volume prints 313 Indians in Dukes County in 1765. It does not give them by town, and the 1765 town counts leave them out.
The 1905 state census counted 23 persons the census recorded as “colored” (2.0 percent) among 1,175 people in Edgartown, and no Indian or Chinese or Japanese persons.
Earle’s 1861 report to the Governor and Council counts 74 members of the Chappequiddick group. This is membership as reported by Earle, not residence.
Where these figures come from
- B. Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905, vol. I, the 1765 and 1776 footnotes to “The State” table (p. 902, legend p. 807); archive.org censusofcommonwe190501mass.
- D. Census of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts 1905, vol. I, “Color and Race,” by city and town; archive.org censusofcommonwe190501mass. The five columns add to the 1905 population.
- E. Earle, Report to the Governor and Council concerning the Indians of the Commonwealth (Mass. Senate No. 96, 1861), p. 15; archive.org reporttogoverno01senagoog.
Historic places
On the National Register
Edgartown has 3 listings on the National Register of Historic Places. The first was listed in 1983; the most recent in 1987. A district counts as one listing however many buildings it holds.
All 3 listings, by name (year listed)
- Cape Poge Light (1987)
- Edgartown Harbor Light (1987)
- Edgartown Village Historic District (1983)
Historic places
In the state inventory
The Massachusetts Historical Commission’s inventory holds 607 records for Edgartown: 595 points (buildings, structures, objects and burial grounds) and 12 mapped areas. It records what has been surveyed. A low count means little of the town has been surveyed, not that little happened there. Archaeological sites are left out.
591 of the 595 points carry a construction date. By decade:
No resource in the inventory is dated before 1650.
The styles recorded most often:
- Greek Revival: 139
- Federal: 49
- Colonial Revival: 49
- Victorian Eclectic: 41
- Colonial: 32
Not counted as styles: 119 points marked “No style,” “Not researched” or “Altered beyond recognition.”
Maps
The town on the oldest maps
The oldest 15-minute (1:62,500) sheet from the U.S. Geological Survey that covers the center of Edgartown is the Marthas Vineyard sheet, dated 1887 on the map, from a survey of 1887. 32 USGS map sheets of all scales and editions cover that point. A large town can fall on more than one sheet.
The state asked every town for a plan in 1830. Edgartown’s survives.


Reading room
Edgartown in its own books
1 vital-records volume for Edgartown, scanned by the Internet Archive and published before 1927. Each page opens beside its text, which you can search.
| Volume | Published | |
|---|---|---|
| Vital records of Edgartown, Massachusetts, to the year 1850 Vital records · 284 page images Published 1906. Not marked In copyright or access-restricted by the Internet Archive. Public domain by age (imprint 1926 or earlier) is our determination. | 1906 | Read On archive.org |
Names
Family names
Family names
122 surnames in Edgartown’s vital records
504 heading lines in the volumes to 1850, each linked to its page.
Open the names ›Next door
Neighboring towns
The towns that touch Edgartown:
Sources, rights and limits
- Settlement and incorporation. State Library of Massachusetts, “Cities and Towns of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts at 250,” citing the Secretary of the Commonwealth. State public record; no license stated. Read 6 November 2026; 199 of 351 towns compiled. Where it has no row we use the Secretary of the Commonwealth’s 1920 Historical Data Relating to Counties, Cities and Towns in Massachusetts (public domain by age).
- Population. U.S. Census Bureau and Massachusetts state censuses and provincial counts, public domain; the source of each figure is in the table above. Figures read from scanned tables were kept only where a printed county total confirmed them.
- National Register. National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places spatial data, queried 6 November 2026. U.S. government work, public domain. The layer is for general reference, and the Park Service withholds sensitive listings. Listings are placed in a town by the city in the listing, checked against the map point.
- State inventory. Massachusetts Historical Commission’s inventory (MACRIS data) as published by MassGIS, provided 4 June 2026. State data; no license stated. It does not substitute for review by the Commission. About 0.4% of points fall in a different town on our map than the layer names; we use the layer’s name.
- Maps. U.S. Geological Survey Historical Topographic Map Collection catalogue, 6 November 2026; USGS work, public domain. 1830 plans: Massachusetts Archives, via Digital Commonwealth.
- Scanned volumes. Internet Archive, with its OCR text. Volumes dated 1926 or earlier and not marked In copyright; public domain by age is our determination, not the Archive’s. Page numbers in the viewer are scan images, not printed pages.