House · Democrat
Jennifer Balinsky Armini
Data through FY2026; built November 9, 2026.
Residence
Marblehead
First elected
House 2022
| Session | Chamber | District | Lines | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 193rd (2023–24) | House | 8th Essex | 2021 lines | |
| 194th (2025–26) | House | 8th Essex | 2021 lines |
Priorities and roles
Jennifer Balinsky Armini: roles and priorities, from the public record.
Roles
- Vice Chair, House Committee on Human Resources and Employee Engagement
What they work on most
- Environment, energy and utilities (9 of 24 lead bills since 2023)
- Taxes and revenue (4 of 24 lead bills since 2023)
- Municipal government (3 of 24 lead bills since 2023)
Topic is the committee a bill was first sent to for a hearing, not a reading of the bill itself.
What became law
Five of Armini’s bills became law.
In their own words
Jennifer Balinsky Armini on malegislature.gov: official biography
The district
8th Essex on its 2021 lines: 3 cities and towns, 43,329 residents (2020).
Marblehead · Swampscott · Lynn
District lines in effect from January 2023 (the 2021 redistricting), from the Census Bureau’s TIGER/Line 2023 state legislative districts, simplified for the web. Basemap: MassGIS.
Percentages are each place’s share of the district’s 2020 residents; for a town split between districts, the share of the town inside this one follows.
Population-weighted Fairness Index of the district’s cities and towns: 37 for all state aid and 36 for discretionary money (50 is a fair share).
Local earmarks are counted three ways. District money uses the first, money to the city and town governments in the district; the second table adds organizations (placed in the district) and state facilities located there (everything placed). Three ways to count a local earmark.
| Session | District | Dollars | In corrective clauses | Per resident per budget, rank | Without corrective clauses, rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 193rd (2023–24) | 8th Essex | $218,000 | $0 | $2.52 · 100th of 160 | $2.52 · 98th of 160 |
| 194th (2025–26) | 8th Essex | $168,000 | $0 | $3.89 · 68th of 160 | $3.89 · 64th of 160 |
District money is where enacted earmarks land, by the place a clause names, mapped to districts by 2020 population; it is not attributed to the member and does not include leadership’s base-text money that names no place. Ranks are of district money per resident among the chamber’s districts, 1 = most. “In corrective clauses” is the part carried by a Ways and Means chair’s corrective amendments, which is leadership’s money; the last column gives the per-resident figure and rank without it. Sessions are labeled by the General Court that enacted each budget. Per-resident figures use the district as drawn for each session (2011 lines through the 192nd General Court, 2021 lines from the 193rd), so they will not equal a session’s dollars divided by the resident count above.
| Session | District | Placed in the district | Per resident per budget, rank | Everything placed | Per resident per budget, rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 193rd (2023–24) | 8th Essex | $379,000 | $4.37 · 140th of 160 | $414,000 | $4.78 · 142nd of 160 |
| 194th (2025–26) | 8th Essex | $217,000 | $5.02 · 118th of 160 | $231,000 | $5.34 · 120th of 160 |
Post and district money
A stipended post in one of two sessions; district money per resident above the chamber’s middle district in one of two.
| Session | Post | Stipends paid in the session’s years | District money per resident per budget, without corrective clauses, rank | Against the chamber’s middle district |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 193rd (2023–24) | No post recorded | none | $2.52 · 98th of 160 | 0.75× |
| 194th (2025–26) | Vice chair, House Committee on Human Resources and Employee Engagement | $13,824 | $3.89 · 64th of 160 | 1.22× |
Stipends are calendar-year payroll: each session shows its two years, and the 194th shows 2025 and 2026 to date. District money for the 194th covers the FY2026 budget only. This table sets two public records side by side: the member’s post and stipends, and the earmark money that landed in the district (the first measure, as in the district table above, without the Ways and Means chairs’ corrective clauses, which are leadership’s money). It does not show that a post brought money to the district. The last column divides the district’s money per resident by the middle (median) district in the same chamber and session; 1.0× is the middle. Across House Democrats the study finds district money rising with stipend size; in the Senate it does not. See Breadcrumbs and Why towns get what they get.
Recorded votes on accountability measures
Jennifer Balinsky Armini cast 20 yes-or-no votes on the 20 accountability roll calls in this file (six yes, 14 no).
| Date | Measure | Vote | Chamber result |
|---|---|---|---|
| February 1, 2023 | Amendment 7.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Time to review technical/ perfecting amendments | No | Yeas 23, nays 130 |
| February 1, 2023 | Amendment 12.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Review of Consolidated Amendments | No | Yeas 23, nays 130 |
| February 1, 2023 | House rules (H2023), rules package: on adoption of the order (contested meaning) | Yes | Yeas 153, nays 0 |
| February 1, 2023 | Amendment 3.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Local Aid Resolution | No | Yeas 23, nays 130 |
| February 1, 2023 | Amendment 9.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Hearing Schedule | No | Yeas 24, nays 129 |
| February 1, 2023 | Joint rules (H2025), rules package: on adoption of the order (contested meaning) | Yes | Yeas 153, nays 0 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 2.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Roll Calls | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 3.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Formal Session Notification | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 4.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): General Court Audits | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 5.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Opinion of the Justices | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 6.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Committee Polls | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 7.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Committee Poll Notification | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Joint rules (H2026), rules package: on adoption of the order (contested meaning) | Yes | Yeas 128, nays 23 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 18.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Time to Review Legislation | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 17.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Audit by State Auditor | No | Yeas 24, nays 127 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 2.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Committee Polls | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | Amendment 3.0 (Bradley H. Jones, Jr.): Committee Poll Notifications | No | Yeas 23, nays 128 |
| February 25, 2025 | House rules (H2024), rules package: on adoption of the order (contested meaning) | Yes | Yeas 128, nays 23 |
| June 26, 2025 | Joint rules (conference report) (S2545), rules package: on acceptance (contested meaning) | Yes | Yeas 147, nays 2 |
| June 3, 2026 | Engross H.5469 (public records law applied to the Legislature). Reform advocates split (contested meaning) | Yes | Yeas 125, nays 28 |
Votes marked “contested meaning” are rules-package and public-records passage votes; reform advocates were on both sides of them. Descriptions are the project’s plain summaries of each question, or the question as recorded for rules-package roll calls; the official record is on malegislature.gov. Votes are facts; no score is computed.
Posts and stipends
Jennifer Balinsky Armini was paid $13,824 in leadership and committee stipends from 2025 to 2026 (2026 to date).
| Session | Posts | First year | Second year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 193rd (2023–24) | No post recorded | $0 | $0 |
| 194th (2025–26) | Vice chair, House Committee on Human Resources and Employee Engagement | $7,776 | annual rate $7,488 |
Posts: the Legislature’s leadership and roster records as compiled for this project, followed by every committee chair, vice-chair, assistant vice-chair and ranking role in the Legislature’s member profiles for the session; a post recorded in both is listed once. Stipends: additional compensation in the Comptroller’s payroll data (CTHRU dataset 9ttk-7vz6), 2015–2026. For 2026 the table gives the annual rate: the amount paid through October 3, 2026 (21 of 26 pay periods) divided by 21/26; the total in the heading is what was actually paid. Base salary is not included.
Budget amendments
Jennifer Balinsky Armini sponsored 17 budget amendments in FY2017–FY2026, asking for $715,000 in all.
Amendments sponsored
17
FY2017–FY2026 budgets
Adopted, known outcomes
62%
10 of 16
Chamber rate, same ask sizes
64%
expected at the chamber’s rates
Of the 16 with a known outcome, ten were adopted (62%). At the chamber’s adoption rate for amendments of the same size, about ten (64%) would have been.
| Year | Chamber | Amendment | Title | Ask | Outcome | Enacted, strong match |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #640 | Refrigerator and Freezer for the Swampscott Council on Aging | $15,000 | Consolidated; outcome not determinable | |
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #639 | Red Rock Park Improvements | $35,000 | Not in the consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #638 | Planting at Kiley Park | $30,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $15,000 |
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #637 | Swampscott Police Surveillance Vehicles | $35,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #636 | Jackson Park Track and Field Repairs | $35,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $35,000 |
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #634 | Marblehead Police Duty Firearms Upgrades | $35,000 | Not in the consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2026 | House | H4000 #633 | Marblehead Cemetery Infrastructure Repairs | $50,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $50,000 |
| FY2025 | House | H4600 #611 | Revolution 250 Marblehead | $20,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $20,000 |
| FY2025 | House | H4600 #596 | Rehabilitation of Slave Quarters and Kitchen at the Colonial Jeremiah Lee Mansion, a National Historic Site | $25,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $25,000 |
| FY2025 | House | H4600 #589 | Pedestrian Safety in Swampscott | $50,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $35,000 |
| FY2025 | House | H4600 #1195 | Stacey’s Brook | $100,000 | Not in the consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2025 | House | H4600 #1193 | Garden Project for the Brickett Elementary School | $10,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2025 | House | H4600 #1191 | Bathrooms at the Lynn Kiley Park Clubhouse | $25,000 | Not in the consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2024 | House | H3900 #187 | Marblehead Council on Aging Dining Room Project | $50,000 | Not in the consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2024 | House | H3900 #185 | Redd's Pond Retaining Wall and Improvements | $75,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2024 | House | H3900 #183 | Hadley Elementary Pedestrian Safety | $75,000 | Not in the consolidated amendment (inferred) | |
| FY2024 | House | H3900 #180 | Pilayella Algae Clean-Up | $50,000 | In a consolidated amendment (inferred) | $25,000 |
| Year | Amount | Enacted budget text (excerpt) | Amendment |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY2026 | $50,000 | “the town of Marblehead for repairs to the irrigation system and deteriorating structures at Marblehead cemeteries” | H4000 #633 |
| FY2026 | $35,000 | “the town of Swampscott for repairs to the Jackson park track and field at Swampscott high school” | H4000 #636 |
| FY2025 | $35,000 | “street design and permitting to create safe streets around Hadley elementary school in the town of Swampscott” | H4600 #589 |
| FY2025 | $25,000 | “Marblehead to rehabilitate the slave quarters and kitchen at the Colonial Jeremiah Lee Mansion, a national historic site” | H4600 #596 |
| FY2024 | $25,000 (shared two ways) | “the cleanup of Pilayella algae on King’s beach and Long beach in the city of Lynn” | H3900 #180 |
| FY2025 | $20,000 | “Marblehead for the costs of programing and publications related to the commonwealth’s 250th anniversary of the American Revolution” | H4600 #611 |
| FY2026 | $15,000 | “the city of Lynn for planting and landscaping improvements at Kiley park” | H4000 #638 |
Strong matches: 7 enacted items, $205,000 (the member’s share where several amendments claim one clause). A further one weaker text match is not listed; attribution is inferred from amendment text and is less certain there. House attribution is inferred throughout, because the House adopts most amendments inside consolidated amendments.
16 outcomes are inferred by matching amendment text to the House’s consolidated amendments, because the House records most amendments only as “Consolidated A–G.” Ask size is the larger of the earmark dollars and the line-item change an amendment requests; bands: no dollar amount, under $50,000, $50,000–$250,000, $250,000–$1 million, $1–5 million, $5 million or more. Leadership’s unattributed base-text and corrective-amendment money is never assigned to a member. The comparison describes outcomes; it is not a measure of merit.
Bills sponsored
Jennifer Balinsky Armini filed 24 bills as lead sponsor in these sessions; five were enacted on their own. In completed sessions, 14% of their lead bills were enacted on their own, against a chamber median of 3% for the same sessions.
Most bills die in every legislature, and many policies pass inside other bills; the chamber median for the same session is the fair comparison.
| Session | Chamber | Lead bills | Enacted | Sent to study | No action | Pending (session open) | Enacted rate | Chamber median | Cosponsored |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 193rd (2023–24) | House | 7 | 1 | 1 | 5 | 0 | 14% | 3% | 224 |
| 194th (2025–26) | House | 17 | 4 | 7 | 0 | 6 | 24%* | 2% | 103 |
| Session | Bill | Title | Committee | Outcome | Chapter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 194th | H110 | An Act relative to lobstering closure mitigation | Agriculture | Pending (session open) | |
| 194th | H1580 | An Act relative to the charitable immunity cap for cases involving sexual abuse | The Judiciary | Pending (session open) | |
| 194th | H199 | An Act to amend the safe haven law to extend the timeframe for voluntary placement of newborns | Children, Families and Persons with Disabilities | Pending (session open) | |
| 194th | H2362 | An Act relative to chaperones for medical exams | Public Health | Pending (session open) | |
| 194th | H2743 | An Act relative to harbormasters | Public Service | Sent to study | |
| 194th | H3285 | An Act establishing the official marine flora of the Commonwealth | State Administration and Regulatory Oversight | Pending (session open) | |
| 194th | H3445 | An Act to promote solar panel installations on school property | Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy | Sent to study | |
| 194th | H3446 | An Act relative to municipal voices in gas utility work | Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy | Sent to study | |
| 194th | H3609 | An Act to promote safe bicycle yielding | Transportation | Sent to study | |
| 194th | H3912 | An Act increasing the membership of the board of health of the town of Marblehead from three members to five | Municipalities and Regional Government | Enacted | Chapter 90 of the Acts of 2025 |
| 194th | H3917 | An Act updating the tax treatment of recreational lands in the town of Swampscott | Revenue | Pending (session open) | |
| 194th | H3966 | An Act to reform property tax assessments and abatement processes | Revenue | Sent to study | |
| 194th | H4225 | An Act authorizing the town of Marblehead to establish a means-tested senior citizen property tax exemption | Revenue | Enacted | Chapter 67 of the Acts of 2026 |
| 194th | H4438 | An Act relative to the charter of the town of Swampscott establishing a fall annual town meeting | Municipalities and Regional Government | Enacted | Chapter 32 of the Acts of 2026 |
| 194th | H4444 | An Act relative to a real property exemption for disabled persons in the town of Swampscott | Revenue | Enacted | Chapter 198 of the Acts of 2026 |
| 194th | H888 | An Act relative to recreation on private tidelands | Environment and Natural Resources | Sent to study | |
| 194th | H889 | An Act relative to boat wrap recycling | Environment and Natural Resources | Sent to study | |
| 193rd | H3135 | An Act relative to monthly minimum reliability contributions | Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy | No action | |
| 193rd | H3136 | An Act to promote solar panel installations on school property | Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy | No action | |
| 193rd | H3137 | An Act relative to intervenors and utility work | Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy | No action | |
| 193rd | H3673 | An Act providing safe, reliable, and equitable access to electric vehicle charging stations | Telecommunications, Utilities and Energy | No action | |
| 193rd | H3702 | An Act to promote safe bicycle yielding | Transportation | Sent to study | |
| 193rd | H3919 | An Act relative to boat wrap recycling | Environment and Natural Resources | No action | |
| 193rd | H4086 | An Act amending the charter of the town of Swampscott | Municipalities and Regional Government | Enacted | Chapter 261 of the Acts of 2024 |
Outcomes are the furthest point each bill reached in the record. “Folded into a bill that became law” means the bill’s history, or the new draft’s, names a new draft, substitute or combined bill that was enacted. The law’s text and title can differ from the original bill: a committee may combine many bills into one draft, and a chamber may replace a draft’s text before it passes. The label shows where the bill’s path ended, not that its contents became law; the enacted-on-its-own count is the stricter measure. A folded bill that landed in the same chapter as another of the member’s enacted bills is the same law and is counted once. “Discharged to another committee, then died” means a committee sent the bill on to a second committee (often Ways and Means) and no further action is recorded; a policy enacted in another bill without a recorded link is not shown as folded. “Passed both branches; no chapter recorded” means the bill was enacted by both branches and laid before the Governor, with no chapter or veto in the history; in the 194th General Court such bills are shown as laid before the Governor (pending). The 194th General Court is in session until January 2027, so its open bills are pending, not dead, and its rates (*) are not comparable with completed sessions. Chairs and leaders control the calendar, which raises their rates. Source: malegislature.gov bill histories.
Campaign money in
Jennifer Balinsky Armini’s committee reported $73,000 in contributions in years the member served, 2023–2026, $45,000 of it in contributions of $250 or more.
Massachusetts campaigns are funded by individuals and organizations. This page reports contributions as filed with the Office of Campaign and Political Finance, and names no individual donor.
This cycle, 2025–26 to date
$28,000
108th of 159 House members serving now
Last cycle, 2023–24
$45,000
in the Legislature that cycle
Since 2015, years served
$73,000
2023–2026 · $45,000 of it $250 or more
Cash on hand
$52,000
as of September 30, 2026 · 57th of 158 House members
Contributions are every gift to the member’s own candidate committee as filed with the Office of Campaign and Political Finance, from individuals, political committees, unions and associations, including small gifts the committee reported only as a total. Candidate loans, the candidate’s own money, transfers, refunds, interest and contributions the committee refunded are not counted. The compilation begins in 2015, so for members first elected earlier this is not a career total. The ranks compare members serving now in the same chamber. Cash on hand is the committee’s balance at its latest bank report.
Who gave, by how much each giver gave in the cycle
143 givers and $28,000 in this cycle; 99th of 159 House members serving now by number of givers; 3.3 givers per 1,000 district residents (43,329, 2020).
| Where | Givers | Share | Dollars | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| In the district | 100 | 70% | $17,000 | 62% |
| Elsewhere in Massachusetts | 30 | 21% | $7,700 | 27% |
| Outside Massachusetts | 6 | 4% | $1,986 | 7% |
| Address not matched | 7 | 5% | $1,000 | 4% |
186 givers and $45,000 in this cycle; 4.3 givers per 1,000 district residents (43,329, 2020).
| Where | Givers | Share | Dollars | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| In the district | 130 | 70% | $30,000 | 68% |
| Elsewhere in Massachusetts | 36 | 19% | $10,000 | 22% |
| Outside Massachusetts | 9 | 5% | $3,050 | 7% |
| Address not matched | 11 | 6% | $1,450 | 3% |
Each giver’s contributions to the committee in the two-year cycle are added together, so ten gifts of $100 count as one giver of $1,000. A giver is an individual (matched on name and ZIP code; a person who moved may count twice) or an organization. An individual may give a candidate $1,000 a calendar year, $2,000 a cycle; a political action committee $500 a year. People who gave $50 or less in a year may be reported only as a total; they are shown as at least that total divided by $50 givers and are not in the share of givers. The tick on each bar is the share for all legislators in the same cycle. Individual givers are never named.
Armini drew 2.3 givers per 1,000 residents from the district, 1.7 times the House median of 1.3; 3.3 counting all givers, below the House median of 4.2.
Top leadershipOther leadership or committee chairVice chair or other postNo post
Givers per 1,000 district residents (2020), 2025–26 to date. Each dot is a House member serving now; Jennifer Balinsky Armini is the green dot, and the line is the median; the other dots are colored by each member’s post this session. Point to a dot for the member’s name, post, rank, givers and the givers’ dollars; click it for their page. Both rows use the same scale; dots past 20 are drawn at the edge. A giver is an individual or organization that gave the member’s committee in the cycle, itemized givers only; “live in the district” uses each giver’s street address placed on the district map. Members with few givers on file may not be raising money this cycle, or their reports may trail.
| Year | All contributions | $250 or more |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | $17,000 | $10,000 |
| 2024 | $28,000 | $18,000 |
| 2025 | $24,000 | $14,000 |
| 2026 | $4,100 | $2,800 |
| Kind | Total | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Individuals | $41,000 | 92% |
| Political committees and PACs | $3,300 | 7% |
| Unions and associations | $500 | 1% |
| Employer reported | Share |
|---|---|
| A named employer | 45% |
| Self-employed | 11% |
| Retired | 10% |
| Not employed | 27% |
| Not reported or withheld | 7% |
Not counted as contributions: $500 in other receipts of $250 or more in the same years (candidate loans and the candidate’s own money, transfers between the committee’s own accounts, refunds and reimbursements the committee received, contributions the committee later refunded, bank interest and aggregated small receipts).
The same committee also reported $48,000 in years the member was not in the Legislature (2022), for example while running for another office. Those receipts are not in the totals above.
| Organization | Kind | Total | Contributions | Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MA & NORTHERN NE LABORERS' DISTRICT COUNCIL POL ACTION COMM | committee or PAC | $1,500 | 3 | 2023, 2025, 2026 |
| 1199 SEIU - MA PAC | committee or PAC | $500 | 1 | 2024 |
| LOCAL 509 SERVICE EMPLOYEES INT'L UNION COMM ON POL ED MA WORKERS' POL ACTION COMM | committee or PAC | $500 | 2 | 2024, 2026 |
| MA & NO NEW ENGLAND LABORERS' DISTRICT COUNCIL | union or association | $500 | 1 | 2024 |
| MASSACHUSETTS HEALTH AND HOSPITAL | committee or PAC | $300 | 1 | 2026 |
| CARPENTERS LOCAL UNION 339 POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE | committee or PAC | $250 | 1 | 2024 |
| MARBLEHEAD DEMOCRATIC TOWN COMMITTEE | committee or PAC | $250 | 1 | 2024 |
Individual contributors are not named here. Their itemized contributions are public at the Office of Campaign and Political Finance: Armini Committee (CPF 17981).
Source: Office of Campaign and Political Finance, itemized receipts of $250 or more since 2015; OCPF filer record: Armini Committee (CPF 17981). Individuals are grouped by the employer they reported; no individual contributor is named, and an employer field that is a person’s name is withheld. Massachusetts bars business contributions to candidates; where a business or a foreign government appears in the list, the kind column gives the type it was filed under with OCPF. Employer shows affiliation, not instruction.
Sources
Every figure traces to a public record.
- Massachusetts Legislature, members, districts and roll calls
- Budget amendments and enacted budgets, FY2017–FY2026
- CTHRU payroll, Office of the Comptroller (stipends)
- Office of Campaign and Political Finance
- District lines: Acts of 2011 and 2021; Census 2020 block populations
- Official profile (prior offices, occupation)
- Election statistics (first elected, residence)
Facts only: posts, stipends, sponsored amendments, enacted items, roll-call votes and district money. No score or grade is computed. Associations shown here are not evidence of cause. Method.
Massanomics Weekly Every Tuesday
Your city or town, in the numbers that matter.
- This week’s story, with where your city or town stands
- Economics, housing and the state money that reaches you
- Land, climate, history and politics
- Side-by-side findings that show how it all connects